Thursday, March 7, 2013

Review: Fire Emblem: Awakening

Fire Emblem: Awakening is a strategy RPG put out by Nintendo that was recently released on the 3DS. The whole Fire Emblem series has a few unique things that make it stand out among most other strategy RPG's - the most obvious being permadeath to any unit that falls, making it a fairly unforgiving series, although in a series first, you can select whether you want permadeath or not when you make a new file. It also has very similar sets of classes across games - the horse, wyvern, and pegasus riders, archers, mages, thieves, armored fighters, "main character" lord class, berserker, and many others that don't really change from game to game. Units are frequently not terribly customizable, at least not compared to certain other RPGs like Final Fantasy Tactics or Disgaea. Lastly, Fire emblem really shies away from long-range attacks (which makes sense, given the fact that permadeath is a thing) - almost all units can only attack at a range of 1-2 tiles away. There exist a few 2-3 range bows, and some very rare 3-10 range spellbooks, but the vast majority of combat takes place in adjacent or near-adjacent tiles.

First of all, I'd like to say that I'm really enjoying this game. The combat is fun (I'm playing on "classic" mode - which is to say, permadeath enabled, and I've completed my hard file and have started a Lunatic file), and very strategic. The characters are pretty entertaining, and the support system, where you can have characters become closer - which gives some nice combat buffs - is better implemented than ever.

There are a few complaints out there that there are a  distinct game breakers, but aren't there always? They're quite small in number and pretty specific things, though, and it's fairly difficult to accidentally use them to destroy game balance (I'm looking at you, Skyrim). You can also use DLC to grind, which I do actually kind of have an issue with (especially on Lunatic or Lunatic+ difficulties, where it is quite difficult to grind without DLC), but it's not too bad. I'll also say that none of the maps really stood out in my mind after a playthough - they're passable, and fun, but not great.

The biggest complaint about the game I have is the difficulty curve. Especially on the harder difficulties (Lunatic and Lunatic+), the first few missions are just utterly ridiculous. When going through them on Lunatic, I felt like I was playing a puzzle game where I had to place everything just right in order to "solve" it (not to mention get the RNG on my side) rather than a strategy game. This eases up somewhat after the first 4 or so missions (especially if you aren't opposed to grinding on the DLC. but even if you are), but in some ways, that just makes it worse. I definitely feel that the hardest part of the game should not be the beginning of it; that should be the end, when you have mastered the system, rather than when you are just being introduced to it. I've heard that the game gets quite hard again on Lunatic as you approach the end, though, so we'll see about that.

Honestly, it's hard for me to find other big issues with the game. The difficulty curve is by far the biggest one, and I mentioned most of the others that I had issues with already. I wish Nintendo had done things a little differently with the downloadable (both free and paid) characters (namely, that they are allowed to switch to any class you want, while your story characters are restricted - and they also cannot get support bonuses), but I can kind of understand why they did it the way they did. I'd also change a few things about some of the maps, and maybe some of the classes, and maybe add a few supports (though this game already has far more support conversations than any previous Fire Emblem, making this a somewhat ridiculous complaint), as well as change a few things about how the DLC is handled. But overall it's a very well done game that other strategy RPGs could learn a lot from.

Things to remember about Fire Emblem: Awakening:
-Difficulty curves - make them go easy-hard, not hard-easy-maybe back to hard. If you're just introducing people to the mechanics, they shouldn't immediately be faced with the worst the game has to offer.
-Try to avoid making DLC open up completely new avenues of play (read: easy grinding) that make it feel like you're buying power.
-Good class variety and interesting characters bring a *lot* to a game. Character customization gives a game a fair bit of replay value in general and can definitely make up for other flaws in a system.

Saturday, November 17, 2012

My Thoughts on Grinds

So, I've recently been playing a few games (well, one in particular: Castlvania: Harmony of Despair, but also with some WoW and Diablo 3 thrown in) that rely on grinding as one of their main ways to keep players interested. Naturally, not every game needs to have grinding as a part of its gameplay - but any game that wants to keep the players interest for a long period of time has some sort of "rewards over time" system to keep the player's motivated. Some, naturally, work better than others. So I'm just gonna throw down a few different examples here and see where I feel they go right and wrong.

First, as I mentioned, is Castlevania: Harmony of Despair. It's a very fun (and distressingly addictive) game in which you can play as one of several Castlevania heroes in typical 2-d platforming style over a number of levels and gain power for them via loot, spell collection, or just generally using the same sub-weapons over and over (and over) in order to raise their power (occasionally granting them new properties) as well as raise the overall power of your character. Characters in the game build power in different ways - all the characters have equipment (and a large selection of rare drops), though some are more dependent on equipment for their power than others. Many of the characters build power through using their secondary abilities. One character absorbs spells cast by enemies (9 times for each spell to hit max power).

Personally, one problem I have with this system is that several of the characters take a long time to be useful - or at least, to be *interesting,* which is just as important to me. Soma, who uses a lot of equipment but also absorbs souls from enemies to power him, starts with an incredibly generic weapon and a pitiful selection of souls. Moreover, any souls that he happens to be lucky enough to absorb will likely be quite low power, as it takes 9 absorptions for them to hit max power (which in turn scales with your gear quality). Until you get good equipment, Soma is obnoxiously generic. Alucard, who learns a few spells but mostly gains his power from gear, is in a similar situation. Charlotte has it bad too, especially if you want to play multiplayer - making other people wait for you to try to absorb a new spell (9 times per spell!) just doesn't work. And the game definitely encourages you to play multiplayer in other ways.

So, one lesson to be learned from this is that if you're going to have characters gain power solely through long grinds, don't make them start at absolutely nothing. Give them a decent amount of power at the beginning, and then build from there. Another - make sure that your grinds are compatible with the playstyle of your game. Never make an entire group wait for you - especially for something that takes an indeterminant amount of time, based on how often they cast something and how lucky you are with absorbs.

Also, don't make your grinds *obnoxiously* long. Of course, what qualifies as obnoxiously long varies from person to person, but it should not take hours of grinding in a very specific, relatively boring way to level up one specific ability when the real reward is for leveling up *all* of your abilities, including the ones that you never use otherwise. Another point here - don't make the player use abilities that they would never otherwise use in order to gain power on the things that they actually do use. At least, don't go overboard with it.

Another thing that HoD sometimes succeeds at and sometimes fails at is having regular, meaningful milestones along the grind. Sometime abilities change after x uses, sometimes they don't. When you'll want to level all of them up to gain your max power, then having checkpoints that feel like genuine boosts in power - and not just numerical ones - is quite nice.

Balance different grinding paths. Characters should not be extremely useless compared to other characters at any point in the grind. Soma falls victim to this at both ends - at the beginning of the game, he is extremely generic and not especially effective, though he's workable. But once you get the thing you need to grind him properly, and do some of that grinding, he gains a ridiculous number of options, many of which are quite powerful, largely because his unique weapons power him up as well as the souls he collects to give him more abilities. He is well known for being the game's most powerful character, and for good reason - though a few particularly out-of-balance pieces of equipment are largely to blame for that as well, the sheer variety of abilities he has already makes him very powerful. At any given point, no character (or general grinding option) should feel significantly superior or inferior to any other. Or at least, don't make those points long - it's okay to give someone a big boost of power at certain singular points in a grind, but whatever they gain shouldn't be *too* huge a boost as to invalidate other options, and things should align themselves again not too long after that boost, if nothing else in a similar boost to the other options of grind.

I kinda got off track here, and only really talked about Castlevania. I've been playing it a *lot* lately, so cut me a little slack. I may well do a second post about this. But here's the gist of things:

-Grinds should have regular, genuinely rewarding milestones.
-The end of a grind should always be visible, even if its in the horizon. Don't make it in such a way as to overwhelm the player - don't make them do 12 separate *long* grinds to make their characters gain their full power.
-Reward the player for things that they already do; don't make them change their playstyle significantly to accomodate a grind. As a corollary, make whatever the grind is be based on the part of the game that is the most fun. The grinding itself *must be fun to start with*, otherwise you're dead in the water.
-In the case of grinds that can be chosen, one or the other, for theoretically similar end results (character classes, ability trees, what have you), keep them as balanced as you can for all points in the grind. And as a corollary, make the grinds of as close to equal length as you can.

Tuesday, September 4, 2012

Review: Persona 4 Arena

Persona 4 Arena is a fighting game made by Arc System Works, makers of BlazBlue and Guilty Gear, with its story and character design being done by Atlus, who has made the Persona series. Even though I'm not usually one to play fighting games, I'm really enjoying this one - the characters and story that I recognize drew me into it, but the surprisingly easy to pick up gameplay has kept me here.

The first thing I'd like to talk about for this game is the story mode. As the game is a fighting game, you wouldn't normally expect that much from it - however, it is actually quite entertaining, and quite important to the Persona series. It connects Persona 3 and Persona 4, while setting the stage for another game in the series - possibly Persona 5, or perhaps another side game like this one. Regardless, the overall story is quite enjoyable - though the first of its flaws is that it is likely to be almost completely inaccessible to someone who has played neither of the previous games, and even missing one of them would significantly cut into your enjoyment of it.

Another problem with the story mode is the exceptionally high ratio of story to gameplay. It's not a deal-breaker, but the fact that after starting the story mode with most characters (each character has a separate story mode), you have to wait upwards of twenty minutes to get to the first fight. And, oddly, those fights are only ever one-round affairs, with no option to adjust this. Clearly, the game's developers wanted to get you back to the story and out of the fighting quickly, but I definitely don't agree with this decision. One of the stories has only one fight in its roughly two and a half hour duration - though it has the most engaging and interesting of the stories, so it can be forgiven for this. Regardless, I can see why they designed the game they did - having characters fight for no reason is a common problem in fighting game stories, and this game manages to avert that pretty well - but the fact that there's not even a way to increase the number of rounds in a story mode fight seems like a poor choice to me.

This problem is compounded by the fact that the stories of almost every character tell the same events, but from a slightly different perspective. This would be a difficult thing to change, but it certainly seems like perhaps some of the stories could have been combined in order to make the experience less repetitive. It's interesting to see every angle to each event, but it becomes overkill after a while.

But this is a fighting game, after all! So what about the fighting?

I personally find the fighting in this game to very enjoyable. As I mentioned above, I'm not really a fighting game guy - I've played a few, but the only other fighting games that I own/have spent a significant amount of time with are Marvel vs Capcom 3 and the Smash Bros series - the former of which enticed me with its interesting characters and "deckbuilding" aspect of picking your team, and the latter of which also grabbed me with its characters, but also its discarding of many of the things that make fighting games inaccessible (and typically uninteresting) to me. So, as a novice fighting game player, I'm very appreciative of some of the changes they've made in this game. Many of the more complex joystick motions of other fighting games have been cut out entirely - the only motion required for a single move is rolling the joystick from down to forward or down to backward - twice in a row for super moves. Most of the two-button and three-button combinations do something when pressed at the same time that, in some other games, would require a more complex input for at least a few of them - and several these two and three button inputs can conveniently mapped to shoulder buttons. Last, and perhaps most helpfully, there is an auto-combo feature - if you just keep mashing square (on the PS3), your character will do a five-move combo, ending with a super if you have the meter for it. These combos are far less effective than true, more conventional combos would be (though certain characters have more usable auto-combos than others), but they provide an excellent way to allow beginners to not be overwhelmed by the need to learn a relatively complicated (for a beginner) chain of moves to do more than trivial amounts of damage. Lastly, there is also a lesson mode to teach you the basic controls of the game, as well as a challenge mode for each character to show you some of their combos, further increasing the accessibility of the game.

However, I am not personally equipped to speak too much on the mechanics of the game beyond the newbie friendliness of the game. While I am sure that it has its flaws, and someone more experienced with fighting games could point them out to you, it is simply lots of fun to me. For once, it's a fighting game that makes it unintimidating to look at your character's command list, and it's not too hard to do any of the moves there for a novice to the genre. I feel like I'm using the full power of my character when I play him , even though I know that I'm not, and that's a great feeling. I think that attempting to capture this feeling (by making basic moves and combos easier to do) is what other fighting games should try to do in order to draw in a bigger audience.

And on a side note, the online play is amazingly lag free. It is exceptionally rare that I really notice a difference between online and local play (though I'm sure someone who relied more on real combos would notice it more), at least if you let the intro play long enough to sync the two players. While not a huge deal in terms of game design, it is very nice, and having netcode this good definitely helps to keep me playing online.

One last flaw I'd like to discuss is the DLC - specifically, four navigators (read: match commentators who are characters from the series) which are overpriced online, but are also unlockable in-game. I do really like this model (well, not the overpriced part, but the unlockable in-game or DLC part), but these four particular unlocks are all hidden behind the hardest portion of the game - score attack. Score attack mode consists of putting you up against extremely powerful versions of all 13 characters, one after the other, with any failure sending you back to the beginning of the mode. This is bad enough, but to unlock each of the navigators, you have to beat this mode with a certain combination of three or four of the characters. In other words, it really gives the sense that these navigators, while technically unlockable in-game, are so difficult to obtain that only an extremely tiny portion of the playerbase would be able to get them - but, hehe, if you really want them, you can just buy them online for a mere three dollars each! While I'm all for rewarding players for difficult feats, beating this mode with even one character is hard enough - beating it with several characters, many of whom play quite differently from the character you like to play as, is effectively impossible for those who don't want to spend literally days on this mode.

Anyway, as should be obvious, while this game definitely has flaws, I'm really enjoying it. I think that it's a great example of what fighting games can do to be more user-friendly, as well as having an interesting and engaging plot.


Things I can learn from this game:
-Make your player feel like he is using the full power of his chosen character. This can be accomplished by not making your character have crazy awesome moves that require appropriately crazy inputs - or at least by making the easier-to-use moves feel sufficiently powerful. This applies to any sort of combo system the game might have as well - have some sort of very easy but usably effective place to start.
-Try to avoid repetition in game modes - particularly story modes, where you'd just be seeing the same thing over and over, and with minimal combat gameplay. Combine separate stories into one, create further differentiation between them, whatever.
-Allowing things to be unlocked either in-game or by spending money is a pretty good model. However, don't use this to hide unlockables behind such ridiculous requirements that the content is effectively unlockable only by spending money.
-For games where each character plays significantly differently (and players frequently have the choice of which character to play as), don't force us to play at extremely high levels as multiple characters in order to unlock things.

Monday, August 6, 2012

Review: Donkey Kong Country Returns

Donkey Kong Country Returns is a 2-d platformer for the Nintendo Wii, and a game that I very much enjoyed playing through. It isn't without flaws, but has incredibly few, and those handful are far outweighed by the excellent level design, solid pacing, good collectibles, and overall good character of the game.

First of all, as I mentioned, the level design of this game is generally just excellent. Each level has enough of its own uniqueness to really shine, and even the instant-kill-if-you-screw-up mine cart levels don't come off as too bad, usually thanks to conveniently-placed extra lives, as well as the general number of lives that you get in the game and relative lack of punishment for losing all of them. Individual gimmicks often don't leave the level they are introduced in, which is a little dissapointing when you've beaten them, but each level has enough replay value (usually in the form of collectibles) to make you happy to go back them; it's probably best this way anyway, as overusing some of the more unique gimmicks would probably make them stale. They are often difficult, but checkpoints are usually very well placed so that while you do feel punished for dying, it's not excessive. The difficulty in this game is handled quite well as well - the game starts out pretty easy, but about halfway really kicks it into high gear and only gets harder from there; however, there are items that can be used to make levels *much* easier, as well as a "super guide" option that is becoming more popular in recent Nintendo games, where the game will clear the level for you should you desire it to after a certain number of deaths.

Honestly, it's hard to find words to praise this game. It doesn't do anything incredibly out of the ordinary, it doesn't have any particular mechanic that makes the game incredibly fun (except, perhaps, for the unexpected (and welcome) high (but fair) level of difficulty), and no aspect of the game stands out as the most praiseworthy. It simply delivers incredibly solid base mechanics combined with extremely good level design sprinkled with enough gimmicks to keep it from becoming dull. It's just an all-around amazing game.

However, as I said, I definitely do not think the game could not be improved. Firstly, I think that the "hidden" items are too often hidden in exactly the same places throughout the different levels. After you've played the game for a while, it was frequently *very* obvious where a hidden item was just by glancing at the area. A certain amount of this is fine (and good, even), of course, and even late in the game the game did sometimes surprise me, but far too often it was just too obvious where the hidden items were. The biggest offender in this was heading left from the start of the level - something like a full quarter (maybe more) of the levels had something "hidden" right there. Additionally, the mini-games to get the hidden puzzle pieces became repetitive pretty quickly - there definitely could've been more variety there.

The co-op play, while definitely fun, also had some pretty large flaws, to me. The player who played as Diddy Kong received a jetpack and peanut-guns, but the player who played as Donkey Kong received nothing in return; making the second player noticeably more powerful than the first. Additionally, if they players chose to have Diddy ride on Donkey's back (a good inclusion in the game, as some of the puzzles become much harder if one tries to tackle them seperately), all the second player can do is shoot peanuts in a predetermined path - they cannot even aim their shots. My personal changes here would be to take away something from Diddy that only Donkey can do (probably give him a worse base attack and a weaker ground pound), and allow Diddy to aim his peanuts to make the second player more interactive while in a combined form - perhaps using an onscreen cursor. Another problem is that the final unlockable mode (1 health, no diddy, no items, mirrored levels), which serves as one last, long challenge to the player after having completed pretty much everything in the game, cannot be played co-op. While I don't see a good way to make it playable co-op and still maintain the intended level of challenge, it's still frustrating to see the (potentially quite long) final challenge of the game to be inaccessible to two people who have played the game together up until that point.

(On a side note, I wouldn't balance the co-op by adding new powers to Donkey when Diddy leaves his back, as that would be weird with the single-player and Diddy's status in it as just an upgrade. Rather, Diddy should simply have weaker abilities in certain areas than Donkey's standard ones.)

Two smaller complaints that I have is that 1) the final boss battle, upon death, denies you Diddy Kong, making him much harder on later attempts than your first attempt on him, and 2) the reward for beating all the hidden levels is somewhat unsatisfying. You get one new (incredibly bizarre, and not nearly as difficult as some of the levels you had to beat to access it) level, and then you unlock the above-mentioned extremely difficult final mode of the game. The single level feels tacked-on due to its relative shortness and lack of extreme difficulty (and, as I mentioned, just has a very strange design), and the unlockable reward, while good on its own, feels like a strange prize for beating that level. I have heard, however, that that one level was initially supposed to be an entire new world and was cut for time purposes, which would explain it.

All in all, as I said, this was a great, fun game with only couple of minor flaws. My lessons learned would ultimately be this:

-As if it wasn't already obvious, a game doesn't have to have big innovations to be great - sometimes playing it safe is perfectly fine. Solid gameplay with extremely good level design can make a great game all by itself.
-Co-op should be balanced - ideally, if there are different characters, they should have different (but at least theoretically balanced) abilities.
-If a player respawns right at the beginning of a boss (or any particularly challenging area) upon death, he should do so at full power or at the power at which he first made it to the boss. This could probably be expanded further into a whole post covering when to give the player expendable things for free (and when to deny the player them), but that is a post for another time.

Tuesday, July 17, 2012

Review: Theatrythm Final Fantasy

With a rather odd name and an appropriately odd concept to go along with it, Theatrythm Final Fantasy is (in my opinion) the latest in the small-but-growing number of non-rerelease/remake 3DS games worth purchasing. It is a hybrid RPG/Rhythm game, using the music from final fantasy games in a very Elite Beat Agents way.

Personally, I think the RPG and Rhythm game elements could be better integrated in this game. The game does a fairly good job of making them relevant to each other, but ultimately doesn't do it in as good a way as you would hope. For instance - the scoring system doesn't care about the RPG elements of the game at all; any character, item, or ability selections that you make for the level are completely irrelevant in terms of your final score. That isn't to say they're completely irrelevant overall - your characters' collective HP (and any defensive items/abilities you choose) determine how many notes you can miss and still live, and various abilities will help you kill monsters more quickly or walk further in different types of levels, giving you better loot or more experience for your characters. It's nice that there is progression for your characters, but the fact that they don't actually help you get the highest scores for each level (other than letting you live longer) is frustrating.

Similarly, in the Dark Note mode, the game is all about character advancement - this mode is much more focused on leveling your characters and collecting loot. You go through a "field" level first, getting some loot and experience and determining which bosses you can then face in the second, "battle" level. You definitely want to kill the bosses in the battle levels, as they drop the best loot - including the crystals that unlock more characters. As you level up, you get dark notes of a higher difficulty that give correspondingly better loot.

As an aside, the dark note sections use a mere 20 of the 70+ songs that come with the game, and never use DLC songs. Personally, I think designing the game this way was a rather foolish choice, especially considering this mode will be one that more hardcore players will sink a *lot* of time into.

In the dark note sections, the two parts of the game are integrated better, but it still isn't perfect. For one, you're still assigned a score based solely on your rhythm game performance, but it isn't saved and is therefore essentially completely irrelevant. However, it does take a combination of RPG prep and rhythm game skill to actually get good loot from this system, which is nice; however, one problem I have is that the battle songs are still of fixed length in this mode, meaning that you finish them without ever getting to the bosses if you stack defensive abilities or simply aren't using high enough level characters - meaning you can "win" without actually getting what you want. Personally, I'd make the songs loop until either your characters or the boss is dead in this mode.

Indeed, I'd consider making the battle music loop until a boss enemy is dead for every mode. Really, the battle levels end up feeling less like battles and more like, well, rhythm game levels in which you happen to be watching some guys beating up some other guys with little investment in the outcome. You do want to kill the enemies to get loot, but really, while you may care a little bit about how your guys are doing, the game really doesn't seem to give a hoot, which is frustrating. No record of how well you did in battles is recorded anywhere, in any mode - only the scores in series and challenge mode, as well as simply if you completed the level or not. In dark note mode, the boss's identity and loot is recorded when you defeat them, but there's really no tangible, lasting reward from defeating bosses beyond loot that they happened to drop when defeated. Mind you, the loot can include new ability scrolls and collectibles that can unlock new characters once you get 8 of them, so there is definitely progression, but there is still a distinct feeling that the game doesn't really care how well you do (which you do care about, in dark note mode especially), and in the dark note mode, doesn't even really care too much if you do win any particular level, as it just throws a new level at you whenever you beat one - which, after you beat 50 or so of them, is kind of underwhelming as a reward.

But it is quite a fun game, most definitely; don't get me wrong. The music quality seems to range from above average to outstanding, the character selection (though I might have fewer unlocked from the get-go, and give them more distinct abilities and stats at level 1) and rpg customization is nice, the difficulty range is very solid (though I might unlock the middle difficulty from the get-go, rather than requiring the, for veterans, yawn-inducing basic difficulty to be defeated first), there is quite a lot of content and rewards for completing it (mostly in the form of new characters, but also other collectibles), and the core gameplay is quite solid as well. I definitely like it, but it has distinct flaws.

On a side note, this isn't the first Rhythm Game/RPG hybrid that I've reviewed here - I have also reveiwed the fun little indie game called "Sequence." Sequence is much heavier on the RPG side of things - it has an actual story, VA's, equipment, and fights that end when the monster dies, rather than when the song ends. Of course, those are just design choices, but I do think that Theatrythm could've benefited from an increased RPG focus, and Sequence shows a way that that could've been done. Similarly, Sequence could've benefited from having more (and better) songs to lay its RPG systems on top of, as well as better and deeper character customization.

Overall, here's my design lessons of the day for this game:

-If you're going to have a mode that the players are going to play over and over, try to make is as varied as possible (while still keeping it true to the game, of course).
-Align the rewards and acknowledgements your game gives with the goals of the players. Oftentimes, this isn't a problem by the structure of the game, but if you have optional objectives that you put in place for the player, be sure to properly acknowledge when the player hits them.
-If you're going to hybridize two genres, make sure you incorporate the best aspects of both (that fits in your concept, obviously), and incorporate them in a way that does them justice, rather than just slapping the trappings of one onto the other.
-While unlocking higher difficulties by beating lower ones isn't a bad idea in principle, forcing players to start at the absolute lowest difficulty and work their way up from there - especially in genres where skills from one game are transferable to other games (rhythm games being among the best examples of this) - is something that should be avoided.

Thursday, July 5, 2012

Review: Kid Icarus: Uprising

Kid Icarus: Uprising

Kid Icarus: Uprising is an action game that was released a few months ago on the 3DS, and it very quickly became one of my favorite games. It simply has a ton of content, and its basic gameplay mechanics are quite a lot of fun. Add on a relatively solid online multiplayer, you have a real winner. Of course, it's still not without flaws - the online multiplayer isn't as good as it could be, and the controls, while usable, are difficult to use.

First of all, the single-player content is extremely extensive. There are twenty-five levels, most of which consist of one aerial, star-fox ish part, and a ground part which isn't as easily comparable to any other game, but kind of resembles God of War - the closest analogy I can think of is a 3-d Mega Man X. Regardless, both gameplay styles are fairly fast-paced, and both are pretty solid. The controls for the ground section are a bit dodgy, though - aiming and shooting without two joysticks, or a keyboard and mouse, takes some getting used to. Also, holding the 3DS in such a way as to use the controls (and not being extremely uncomfortable after a few minutes), while definitely possible, requires the use of a non-standard grip or using the 3DS stand that came with the game. Personally, I don't really know how they could have improved the controls. They definitely put a lot of effort into making them customizable, and clearly tried to make it work (thus the stand). But they're still awkward, regardless.

But anyway, the actual replayability for the single-player game comes from three things - forging custom weapons (along with collecting weapons and powers), the difficulty slider increasing the difficulty of any level to an extremely high level, and the achievement system. Forging custom weapons typically requires a fair bit of farming to collect weapons with properties, and then finding a way to combine them into something that you want. Fusion is very fickle, though, and to get a weapon with *exactly* what you want, you'll need to do a *lot* of farming. Personally, I generally like how they did it, but I feel that some greater degree of control over the final product would be very helpful. It is almost entirely out of the player's control if a weapon fusion results in anything usable or not, and while that does add replayability, it also really hurts usability. Also, power collection is quite uncontrollable as well - some way to exert some sort of control over the powers you collect would be very helpful.

The difficulty slider in this game is one of my favorite in any game I've ever seen. The difficulty goes from completely trivial (0.0) to brutally difficult (9.0), and everywhere in between. They really nailed it here. The difficulty scale primarily controls how much damage the enemies do, how much health they have, how fast (and how homing) their bullets are, how often they shoot, and how fast they are. Sadly, it very rarely (if ever) changes any abilities that enemies have, and it almost never adds any new ones. It also only rarely increases the number of enemies that spawn. Still, the changes that are there change the game enough to make it a very different experience when you jump up 2 or more full numbers in difficulty. Honestly, I would change extremely little about the difficulty slider. I will say that the bosses have (far) too little health on anything but the highest difficulties, so I'd increase that, and I would probably add a new ability to each boss if they were played on 9.0 difficulty. Still, those are relatively minor changes to a very good system.

Lastly, the achievement system. It's pretty typical stuff, and encourages you to play in ways that you normally wouldn't, making the game more interesting, and rewarding you for your accomplishments. I'd change one or two things about it - one, the trophies (idols, technically) that you receive through achievements can still be found other ways, which I think is silly - they should be exclusive, in order to be more significant rewards - especially the ones that you get by accomplishing some of the most difficult tasks in the game, like boss battles on hard - perhaps the single hardest thing to do in the game, and your only tangible reward for it is a trophy that you're almost guaranteed to already have at that point. Secondly, I'd get rid of the achievements that more or less amount to "Run through this level on 0.0 using a certain weapon." They're not hard, they're not particularly exciting, and I don't think that they really add anything other than a bit of mindless replayability. Don't get me wrong, I was having enough fun with the game that I did them anyway, but there was definitely room for improvement with them.

And, of course, there's the online multiplayer. Fast-paced, fun, with a solid degree of customization - the gameplay itself is great. However, it really suffers from the lack of any sort of ranking system - meaning that without hunting down people to add to your friends list, the level of challenge the online multiplayer gives will vary greatly from game to game. Additionally, a few more modes would have been nice - FFA and Team Vs are nice, but adding in some sort of co-op, ideally in the form of a horde mode, for example, would have been amazing. What's particularly frustrating is that there is a level in the game that is, more or less, a horde mode, and you even do it co-op with a computer-controlled ally. I really surprised that they would have something like that in the game, but then not make the obvious leap to putting it into multiplayer.

In regards to the online ranking system, though, I have one theory as to why they didn't add it - because the game, I think, is not very balanced, and thus the online multiplayer could devolve into using one of a handful of broken strategies (and not always fun ones - extreme homing shots coming through wall, invisible, invincible snipers, etc), or just dying. If this was the case, and there was then an intentional design decision to not put a ranking system in, then I do respect that decision, but I still disagree with it. Even if online multiplayer at high skill/gear levels wasn't very balanced, I still think that having both a ranked and unranked system would be preferable to the current system. I personally (though I haven't tested the system extensively) don't think that the ranked multiplayer at high levels would be too incredibly overcentralized to suck the fun out of the game, and even though there would be less people in unranked multiplayer if there was a ranked option, I think there would be enough that it would be a viable alternative to playing ranked if you didn't want to deal with ranked shenanigans.

Overall, I really enjoyed this game. But it does have its issues, as I've detailed, and I think that it could have been a noticeably better game with a few changes. Here's what I feel I learned from this game:

-Having a *good* difficulty slider (and ideally, a gear system to support it) adds a great deal of replayability to a game.
-Online multiplayer needs a ranked option in order to remain fun over the long-term for anyone that doesn't feel like seeking out people to play with on the internet.
-More multiplayer modes, more better. Having some sort of PvE cooperative multiplayer that emulates the single-player game could be a good way to get people to transition from single-player to multi-player.

Sunday, February 26, 2012

Review: Skyrim

So often I review cool but obscure games, this time I thought I'd take on something a little more mainstream.

The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim is, for those of you living under a rock, an action-RPG that was released for the PC, Xbox 360, and PS3. I played it on the PS3 (and am still technically playing it there, as I never did finish everything I wanted to, but who does in this game), and first of all, I'd like to say that I had a ton of fun with it. The biggest draw of Skyrim, and the Elder Scrolls series in general, is the gigantic fantasy world sandbox of things to do. Coming up right below the world is the different ways you can customize your character - rather than a class, in this game, you can pick and choose from many different talent trees, and thus create a unique playstyle that fits you.

The game's huge world has so much to do, it's extremely easy to be drawn off track by something interesting - and indeed, I'd argue that that is the whole point of the game. Getting from point A to point B becomes something else entirely when you pass 8 dungeons along the way that you can clear out and loot - often finding something tied to a bigger quest there. The scope of the game is simply incredible, both in terms of the number of things to do and each of these things remains interesting.

With that said, the game has numerous faults. The two biggest problems with this game are bugs and balance. The game is simply inexcusably buggy, even 3+ months after being released. Companions don't level to your character properly. Quests can bug out and become incompletable, preventing progress in fairly major ways. Companions can become stuck in certain zones of the game, meaning that you lose access to them forever - particularly fun if you've also married them. This is to say nothing of the lag issues that plagued the PS3 version until the most recent patch. I understand that a game this large is going to have some bugs, but there is a difference between some bugs and what Skyrim has, especially what it shipped with.

The "balance," such as it is, is also something of a joke. At least in my experience, I had to actively refrain from doing activities I otherwise would have in order to keep the game moderately challenging. Indeed, I'm using what is considered to be one of the weaker playstyles, blaster mage, and on master difficulty I'm still finding the game to be pretty darn easy. And it's simply the easiest thing in the world to ruin the game's balance for yourself by leveling up smithing or enchanting particularly early on (especially smithing - or, god forbid, both). Conjuration is also ridiculously powerful if powerleveled, as I understand it, and in general I'm given to believe that bow-using stealth characters are a particularly broken archetype. Vampire illusionists, from what I understand, can render every single enemy in the game except for dragons completely harmless. And dragons in general are surprisingly anticlimatic fights. Again, in a game this large and characters this customizable, there are bound to be issues, but Skyrim kicks it up a few notches above that.

But, as I said, I did really enjoy the game. I just think that it could have used a lot more time on bug-fixing and balancing.

Some of the lessons I've learned from this game are:
-Having a very customizable character is indeed great. I mentioned the idea in one of my earlier posts, regarding the ability to create your own class for an RPG, but this game takes that and really runs with it.
-Open worlds, as long as they don't feel empty, can make games all by themselves. Throw in enough decently interesting quests here and there, make the many dungeons each at least a little bit unique, and you've got a really fun game pretty much ready to go.

However, I also learned a few more lessons from this game. These lessons I hope that I am never reduced to using:
-A game can incredibly buggy and still ship to great reviews if it is fun enough. In particular, an open world game with lots of content, so that you can at least theoretically avoid the bugs, lends itself to this particularly well.
-Game balance, at least in single player games, can be almost tossed out the window in favor of other aspects of the game, especially at higher levels.

Monday, November 14, 2011

Sequence

Sequence is a fun little RPG/Rhythm indie game that does quite a few things that I'd never really seen before. First of all, obviously, it combines the RPG and Rhythm game genres - your character has three slots of equipment, levels up, and learns spells, but the combat itself is done as a rhythm game - 3 panels of falling arrows (DDR style) control the enemies' attacks (you only ever fight one at a time), your mana generation, and your spells against the enemy. It's quite a fun system, and a very interesting hybrid of two rather divergent genres.

Of course, the game isn't without its flaws. I, personally, am not a fan of how they handle crafting - using experience points as your crafting material means that you have to lose stats in order to gain stats - and if you get unlucky in the crafting system (which gives you a higher chance of successfully crafting something the more experience you spend on it), you can end up losing more stats than you gain by equipping the item you just spent 2 levels making. Admittedly, this doesn't happen too often, but the luck-based and experience-sucking crafting system just don't sit all that well with me - I don't like depowering myself just to make progress in the game - or to give myself questionable stat boosts from newly made equipment

On top of the luck-based crafting system, you also have a severely luck-based item-collection system. All of the materials you need to make your items are random drops from the enemies, each of which can take 2-4 minutes to defeat. Getting the one specific item you want can be a major pain, especially if you need 6 of them for everything you want to make, they have, say, a 60% drop rate, and enemy that gives them is feeling stubborn about handing them over. It can make the game incredibly frustrating.

With all that said, though, despite its distasteful luck-based and experience-sucking game mechanics, the mechanics do come together to form a fun, cohesive (if occasionally frustrating) whole that works just fine as a game - especially a $5 one. One particular other feature I like about this game is the method of unlocking spells - you have to complete a minigame (well, really it's just the main combat but with only one panel, and certain conditions placed on your success) in order to unlock the spell, even once you've assembled the scroll that can teach you it. It's a fun diversion, and makes unlocking a new spell a more dramatic and fun affair than it would otherwise be. With that said, it does require experience to attempt to learn a spell (though there's a practice mode, as well) and I was playing on a difficulty where I didn't really have problems unlocking them. If the spell-unlocking minigames had been harder, then I might well have found them extremely frustrating rather than fun diversions. Also, I would personally ditch the xp cost for attempting to learn a spell and just let you try until you win.

And, of course, I should comment on the main combat itself - while the RPG elements of the game may not be handled the way I think they should, the combat itself is very entertaining. You jump freely between the mana generation, enemy attack, and your attack boards - you have to choose your spells to cast to damage your opponent, then jump over to your attack window and hit the arrows to make them actually cast, while stopping your opponent's attacks from hurting you, all while regenerating mana in your extra time by using that board. It certainly keeps you on your toes, and is altogether quite fun. One of my few complaints for the combat would be that it can go on too long, and losing by time out is quite frustrating - but you do gain experience even if you lose, so it wasn't a complete waste of time. Additionally, random effects in each floor of the world keep combat fairly exciting as well.

All in all, I really enjoyed this game, especially considering the fact that it only set me back five dollars and that it gave me a little over 10 hours of solid fun. It's flawed, but then again, many fun games are - and its flaws don't spoil any of its core mechanics.

Notes:
-Don't make everything luck-based. It may be a decent way to extend your game, but there are other, less frustrating ways to do the same thing.
-Using experience points as currency is risky proposition, especially if there's a chance that they'll just be flushed down the drain with no reward. I don't like it.
-Blending RPG with another genre can be a surprisingly simple affair - just make combat into the second genre, and make the RPG mechanics work with the combat. It sounds like a cop-out, but it can actually work quite well.

Sunday, October 23, 2011

Design: Tetris Platformer

So, over the summer, I took a Game Scripting class. In it, I made a tetris platforming game that I have since expanded somewhat upon, and am still in the process of expanding. Currently, development is in somewhat of a lull - classes are picking up, and I've gotten to a point where I'm fairly happy showing what I've got, even if it doesn't have the full game structure and all the features it will eventually have. It can be found here: http://dl.dropbox.com/u/45496374/Tetris%20Platformer%20-%209-30.zip

Anyway, the basic concept is Tetris - that standard falling blocks, lines clearing that we all know and love - but with the extra twist that in addition to controlling the falling blocks, you control a person inside the tetris well. That person can move and jump, and it's the person's goal to avoid being crushed by the tetris blocks. This, in itself, is fairly easy - but enemies also occasionally fall from the sky into the well, necessitating extra movement there as well. Lastly, pickups that give you points also fall from the sky, meaning that you want to shape your blocks in such a way that it is possible to get to the falling points and away from falling enemies.

It's a fairly simple concept, but it's a lot of fun to play - at least I think so, and I've gotten pretty positive feedback from others. In its current state, it has 3 modes and two difficulties - normal mode, which is a standard tetris well, lava mode, which covers several bottom rows of the well in lava, making it much more difficult for the jumping person, and water mode, where your movement is slowed, jumping ability increased, and you have to get bubbles at least once every 25 seconds or you will drown. Increasing the difficulty decreases your ability to jump, meaning that in standard and lava mode, you can only jump up 1 tile's worth of space (as opposed to 2), and 2 tile's worth in water mode, in which you can normally jump three. Your movement speed is also slowed slight in the harder difficulty.

The initial project in the class was to pick some sort of old, arcade-style game and put your own unique twist on it. I, obviously, chose Tetris. I wanted a puzzley game that wouldn't be too hard for me to make yet could be of a high enough quality - once I put more time and effort into it - to go into my portfolio. I think that I've somewhat accomplished that, but I still definitely have plans to push this game further.

I intend to add sequences of levels that you progress through one at a time, which get harder and harder. I intend to add more types of enemies - ones that shoot, notably - and powerups for the little guy at the bottom. The three modes that currently exist will become "endless" modes. Obviously, the graphics will be improved at some point in here, as will the sound.

I tried to apply the principle of putting the player in an unexpected role in a familiar situation with the design of the game - something that I've found can be quite fun. It's a basic principle of media design, after all - be predictable, but also unpredictable.

In the end, I think that I've created something here that could help me to get a job by showing off my design and scripting skills - something fun, interesting, and at least somewhat original. I hope that anyone reading this enjoys the game as well. Once I make more progress on it, I'll be posting a revised version with exciting new features.

Thursday, October 6, 2011

Chibi-Robo

Chibi-Robo is a very amusing little adventure-platformer (heavy on adventure) game for the Gamecube. The basic premise is that you are a tiny robot whose duty it is to serve a family - and of course, the family is lovably dysfunctional. Not only that, but all of various stuffed animals, action figures, and the like are alive, and usually even more dysfunctional than the humans - the disturbingly nectar-addicted teddy bear, for example, really takes the cake.

Anyway, the actual gameplay consists largely of fetch quests, platforming (often in the form of exploration), and timed minigames. These are quite entertaining - the platforming is aided by the ability to hover briefly, as well as the ability to move around various blocks. You are limited in your ability to explore by your energy - your every action drains Chibi Robo's energy, which can be recharged by plugging yourself into the wall. You also are limited by the day-night cycle, which changes relatively rapidly. The people and other denizens of the house do different things during the day and night.

Your two currencies are a basic form of money, which is used to buy various things to aid and enable exploration, as well as power a very plot-important robot, and your family's love, which increases the amount of energy Chibi-Robo has. These are accumulated not only by doing various quests, but also by mundane things like taking junk to trash cans and wiping up mud. The game, funnily enough, actually manages to make cleaning fun, by offering an immediate reward of one or both of these currencies, which have quite tangible effects in the game.

Beyond the basic game mechanics, the sidequests are intriguing enough to keep you wanting to do them (especially since many of them are accomplished by exploration, taking you to fun places), the gameplay fun enough, and the characters quirky enough to really keep you interested. On top of that, the setting, a house, is a rather odd one for a platformer, and the possibilities for exploration within it keep you going.

To sum up:

-Quirkiness is good, especially if fetch quests are a large part of your gameplay. If you have relatively standard gameplay, spice up the setting and the characters.
-Unconventional settings can work quite well, especially for platformers and adventure games. Having a main character that isn't human lends itself quite well to this, so don't be afraid to run with it.
-This may seem basic, but exploration is plenty compelling if you know that you'll find things in nooks and crannies. I'm not saying that every game needs exploration, but there's a reason that adventure games still exist, even if they're a bit rarer than they used to be. This game is a great example of compelling exploration.

Sunday, October 2, 2011

Ratchet and Clank: A Crack in Time

Ratchet and Clank Future: A Crack in Time is a very entertaining third-person action-adventure game (or third-person shooter, both describe it fairly well), with heavy puzzle and platforming aspects. I enjoyed this game quite a bit. It was the second Ratchet and Clank game I have ever played (with the first being Ratchet: Deadlocked). The game was very clever, which I think is ultimately what I liked most about it.

First of all, I really like the guns. While I realize that most of them
are carryovers from previous Ratchet and Clank games, they nevertheless are very solid and fun. There are a wide variety of guns - ones that hit the major archetypes of guns, such as pistol, sniper rifle, shotgun, and rocket launcher, as well as such additions as the gun that opens a portal to an alternate dimension, which tentacles come out of to attack your opponents, a sonic-powered frog with a strong aoe attack, and a gun which launches heat-seeking sawblades. While they are not perfectly balanced, each weapon has its niche, and each weapon is quite unique. Even the relatively generic weapons are customizable in addition to being able to be leveled up, making them unique while still being familiar.

Secondly, the puzzles were something that I really had never seen before. In them, you can set multiple versions of your character to accomplish different tasks, which would combine to solve the puzzle by activating various switches simultaneously. You do this by recording your actions, and then interacting with the recording. For example, in the simplest one, you record yourself standing on a button, then play that recording while standing on a different button. Since your past self is standing on the first button and you are presently standing on the second, both count as being pressed and the door opens. It is, again, very clever.

Those two things were my favorite parts of the game, though other things are fairly clever about it as well - I'm particularly a fan of the hoverboots, which affords you speed at the cost of exact control (and sadly, you automatically take them off when you equip a gun) Personally, I'd love to see a game where you constantly control like Ratchet with hoverboots, except with the ability to use guns as normal. The general level design, boss design, and other accessories are fairly clever as well.

Long story short:

-Be unique. Be inventive. For instance, put interesting twists on your most basic guns - but don't sacrifice usability to do so. Same with puzzles - it's fine to just make you hit the switch, but put a clever twist on it and it suddenly becomes fun and fresh.
-Moving fast is fun, particularly in an environment that seems to exist to primarily work for slow people. This goes back to an idea I touched on in regards to Geist - breaking the rules that a game seems like it should have (even if it doesn't) is fun. Platformers are about moving slowly and carefully - make the game fast instead. That's what Sonic did, and he did it well. Play with genre conventions.
-Time manipulation in puzzles is fun, if done right.

Tuesday, September 27, 2011

Devil Survivor: Overclocked

Shin Megami Tensei: Devil Survivor is an excellent strategy RPG for the Nintendo DS. It combines the usual strategy RPG tactics-ness with more traditional turn-based combat - whenever you attack an enemy, the game switches to turn-based combat where you can select your moves and try to exploit your enemies' weaknesses, in classic Shin Megami Tensei style. I'm personally a huge fan of the game - the unique take on strategy rpg, the many different demons and the ability to customize them, and overall fairly good pacing and pretty solid game balance. But today, I'm going to be talking more about the new features of the remake than the game itself.

As I said, the original Devil Survivor was for the Nintendo DS, but the remake, Devil Survivor Overclocked, is for the 3ds, and it adds a number of features. It enhances the graphics, adds demons and skills to further refine the game balance, adds achievements which track the various things you have accomplished, and perhaps most importantly, adds additional content in the form of an extra day (the first game consisted of seven days of story) for three of the five endings.

Remakes, ultimately, serve a few different purposes. Commercially, they target two groups - people who never saw the game the first time around, and people who played the game the first time and enjoyed it enough to buy it again with enhanced features. To target the first market, the game has to make a splash, and most certainly have current gen features and graphics. Thus, the graphical overhaul which Overclocked received. Sadly, Overclocked did not make good use of the 3d effects on the 3ds - most of action takes place on the bottom screen, limiting the 3d to the intro and a brief, generic demon fusion animation. In that way, I think it was somewhat of a failure - it is unlikely to draw too many new players in if they know that it doesn't even take advantage of one of the 3ds's main draws.

In terms of improving the game experience, however, the game performs quite well. The rebalanced demons and abilities are fairly well done, with only a few mild exceptions. The biggest draw, the eighth day, is a bit disappointing in that only three of the five endings have it - in a game where the morality is supposed to be somewhat subjective and no path is the right or wrong path (mostly), adding bonus content to some of the paths and not others effectively punishes you in the gameplay for perfectly fine story decisions. This, obviously, isn't ideal, and while the problem existed in the first game as well to a lesser extent, it's exacerbated here. With that said, the choices in which you get no bonus content still wrap up their storylines effectively, and the lack of bonus content isn't too bad, but it's nevertheless fairly annoying. Additionally, the 8th day content that does exist is quite fun and well-made, and doesn't feel simply tacked-on.

All in all, this is certainly the definitive version of Devil Survivor, and I enjoyed it very much and strongly recommend it to anyone who has a 3ds and enjoys strategy RPG's. Here's what I garnered from the experience of the remake:

-While not updating the game's assets to match the current generation for a remake does not take away from the game itself, it makes it less likely that a new player will be interested in the game. Ideally, you want to make the game physically match the current gen.
-New content added in a remake shouldn't feel simply tacked on and should integrate naturally with the existing game.

Monday, September 26, 2011

Magic: The Gathering: Innistrad!

The latest set of Magic: The Gathering just had its prerelease tournaments last weekend, which I attended, and I thought I'd say a few words about the set.

First of all, the flavor of the set (gothic horror), is shown in the cards quite well. Vampires, werewolves, zombies, and spirits (along with humans) are the major players in Innistrad. They each have their own schticks - werewolves transform between human and wolf forms, humans get boosts from various types of equipment and generally for interacting with other humans, vampires suck blood in various ways (gaining power from hurting players, healing the player whenever they deal damage) along with occasionally touching the other archetypal vampire powers (turning into a bat, hypnosis and vampiric conversion), and zombies come in both the garden variety and the frankenstein's monster variant. The frankenstein's monster zombies are portrayed cleverly, and use the graveyard (the mechanical focus of the set) in a clever way - consuming the creatures within it as a requirement to play them (IE, stitching the monster together from the dead creatures).

One thing that I would particularly like to say is that the transformation mechanic for werewolves turned out to be lots of fun. At first, when I saw it, it seemed to be fairly odd and not particularly logical, but after having played with the cards, I enjoyed it quite a bit. They go from human to wolf form when no player casts a spell in a turn, and go from wolf to human when a single player casts two or more spells in a turn. On paper, it seemed to be quite arbitrary, to me, but after having played with them and seen their power, the limitation and interaction of the triggers with the players' actions works quite well. In order to transform your werewolves to wolf form, you have to hold back (most of the time, anyway - you may get lucky and have your opponent play no spells, which is a nice bonus), and in order to force your opponents wolves back to human form, you have to play lots of things, potentially storing up spells to retransform your opponents cards.

All in all, I really liked what I saw of the set. Admittedly, I didn't see that much of it in one night, but I definitely intend to look at it more closely in the coming months. Regardless, the thing I most took out of the prerelease was the following:

-Sometimes, game mechanics that seem clunky at first glance actually work well in practice. Playtesting these mechanics is especially critical - if they don't feel fairly natural to the players in practice, then the players will quickly form negative opinions of them.
-Allowing the players to directly manipulate states of the game by doing things that they would already do, but in slightly different ways than usual, can be quite fun for them.

Tuesday, April 13, 2010

Review: Ace Attorney Investigations: Miles Edgeworth

Ace Attorney Investigations: Miles Edgeworth is the latest game in the Ace Attorney series; a very amusing series of adventure games in which you play an anime-style defense attorney in search of the truth, which consists of both searching for clues in crime scenes as well as defending your clients in court. In this game, however, there is no court aspect; despite the fact that they mixed things up by have you play as the prosecutor from the first 3 games, Miles Edgeworth, you do not actually do any prosecuting. Instead, you simply investigate crime scenes and confront the criminals. This is my first complaint about the game - if a prosecutor is the star, then he should be prosecuting, not doing detective work.

In another change from the standard Ace Attorney gameplay, the investigation parts of the game are conducted from a third-person view, rather than a first-person view. This, I believe, was a good choice - it makes the game feel a little more open, which is something that previous Ace Attorney games lacked. However, it also removed the ability to move freely between areas, which I think was a poor move - when you're investigating an area, that's really the only area you can go to, and you very rarely have to move between areas in the middle of an investigation, though you may after talking to someone to get new information.

The interrogation/rebuttal portions of the game, where you accuse potential criminals or are generally trying to get more information out of people are basically the exact same as they were in previous games - you go through a series of statements, have the option to get more information about each statement, and when you see a contradiction between your evidence and the statement, you present your evidence to point out that contradiction and to advance the game. It's not a bad system, but it's basically unchanged since the first Ace Attorney game, and still occasionally has moments of unintuitiveness.

This game also included a "Logic Mode," which I really enjoyed - Miles Edgeworth is a lot more methodical and less slapdash than the usual main character, Phoenix Wright, for whom a logic mode would not have been in character. However, one of my complaints is that what became a piece of evidence and what became a bit of logic felt quite arbitrary - some integration between logic mode and your evidence would have been nice.

But the real reason to play Ace Attorney games is for the characters, who are universally entertaining, and often hilarious; as well as for the plot. The characters in this game definitely didn't disappoint - Edgeworth was his usual stoic, straight-man self, detective gumshoe was as lovably unhelpful as ever, and all the other characters filled their roles quite well. The plot of the various cases (and overarching plot) was quite entertaining as well. There were, of course, a few hiccups - the final confrontation with the main villain at the end dragged on for ages, for example. But in general, it was very well done.

All in all a good game, but not without its flaws.

Things to learn:
-Don't change things for the sake of change if something works.
-That said, don't allow something to remain stagnant over the course of 5 games.
-Entertaining characters and an intriguing plot can compensate for "eh" gameplay; similarly, gameplay can be relatively simplistic and still end up with an entertaining game.
-Giving hints to solve puzzles, especially puzzles of the "look everywhere until you find something" variety, is a good idea, at least if a player appears stuck.
-Make sure any logic that you require the player to use is sound.
-If the main character has a profession, make sure that he actually uses, especially in a story-centric game.

Saturday, September 12, 2009

Review: Elite Beat Agents

Elite Beat Agents is a very interesting game. It's a rhythm game in which you tap little circles that appear on the bottom screen of the DS in time with music. It sounds very simple - and to an extent, it really is a very simple game. The gameplay itself could almost be a minigame in another game. But Elite Beat Agents has several different things going for it that make it into a full-fledged - and very fun - game.

1. Humor. While you're busy tapping along with the song, the agents are dancing in the background of the bottom screen, and funny stuff is happening on the top screen depending on how well you're doing. Each level has its own plot - someone (or some animal) needs help, and the agents appear and inspire them with song and dance. The situations, what happens during the level, and what happens at the end of the level all definitely serve to inspire you to beat the level, just to see what hilarious thing happens next.

2. Difficulty. The difficulty curve in this game is very good. Levels range from quite easy to nigh-impossible, and there are rewards for high scores (which often require nigh-perfection) on top of that. The curve itself, like I said, is also very good - the levels start easy and ramp up, and as you learn the mechanics of the game and just generally get more skilled, you become able to handle the harder levels that you get access too. Moreover, the rewards for doing well are good enough to keep you coming back - two harder difficulty levels, 3 hidden levels, and assorted useless but cool features, such as viewing brief cinema scenes again or watching the credits.

3. The Songs. The songs themselves are usually pretty good, and they help to keep you interested. They are, above all, catchy (expect to have them stuck in your head for days to come, especially when you have to spend a fair bit of time to beat them on higher difficulties), and though I personally disagree with some of the choices (Skater Boy...), I think that they certainly serve their purpose, and none of them are especially painful to listen to. Plus, if you already know a song going in, you can expect to do a lot better on the song than you would otherwise - I personally always found Material Girl to be easier than other songs of supposedly equal difficulty, for instance. Seeing a song you know show up is a always a pleasant surprise, though be careful - you may think you know a song, only to realize you only know the chorus - this happened to me on ABC, Canned Heat, and others.

4. General Addictive qualities. The game just keeps you coming back for more - if you keep playing over and over, you can beat basically any level, and like I said above, the songs are catchy, the humor is fantastic, and when you finally do beat a level, the sense of accomplishment is great. So basically it comes back, once again, to pacing.


Things I can learn from Elite Beat Agents:

If you infuse the game with enough other positive qualities (music, humor), the basic gameplay of a game can be quite simple and the game itself will still be great.

A good difficulty curve is key in all games, but especially rhythm games, since the only major change in gameplay in rhythm games tends to be the difficulty.

Wednesday, July 1, 2009

Review: Kingdom Hearts 2

And here, after a long break, is my review for Kingdom Hearts 2.

KH2 is, unsurprisingly, very similar to KH1. The main character is (usually) the same, the supporting characters are the same, the gameplay is quite similar. The story is fairly similar as well, as least in terms of traveling from one disney world to another in order to defeat the heartless (or nobodies now, occasionally).

However, KH2 is, by and large, much more polished than the first game. First, and most obviously, the Gummi Ship levels - transition levels between larger disney worlds - are leaps and bounds above the gummi ship levels in KH1. They are no longer all drug-trip themed, the enemies you face are diverse, the gummi ship builder is more helpful and intuitive, and the rewards for doing the levels are much more... rewarding. The levels themselves are all very pretty, and very fast-paced - as it should be with a space-shooter, at least usually. All in all, the whole gummi ship system was revamped, and it shows. It's very, very fun in ways that the original wasn't - it now feels like something that design and testing time went into, and they didn't just shove it onto the main game to have something different in the main game - it is now fun, and not just different.

There are many changes within the main game as well. The combat is still largely the same (mash attack until the bad guy dies), but it has several new and shiny features. First among them is probably the "reaction command" system. Basically, every now and then, a "reaction command" will pop up - the game gives you an interesting combat option if you press triangle. These vary greatly, as anything from 'dodge' to 'grab the axe he dropped and smack him with it.' They do add depth to the system, but they can be ignored most of the time - they do make life easier for you if you do use them, though. I'm not in love with the system, though - it feels kind of limited, like they could've done some of these commands without sticking them onto a whole seperate system.

Secondarily, the magic system has been revamped. All spells other than cure cost a fixed amount of mana, and cure immediately drains all of your mana. Once your mana bar is empty, it automatically refills over a period of time. The end result of this is the opposite of what is the case in KH1 - there, every spell you cast that wasn't cure was largely a waste of mana. Here, spamming other spells is encouraged, because cure, while still the most useful spell in your arsenal, does not have a fixed cost, but simply drains all your mana. Thus, it doesn't matter how much mana you have left when you do finally cast it. It's quite a good system, I think - far better than KH1's system, anyway. The best spell is no longer the only spell you should ever cast.

A few more improvements have been made to the gameplay - one major one is the idea of forms. You can combine Sora with one or both of your party members in order gain a temporary power boost. It's quite nifty, actually - the forms are very fun, and a good addition to a varying arsenal of means of killing your enemies. It's like Star Wars: Force Unleashed - having a vast number of ways to kill your enemies makes random encounters much more interesting.

Navigating the worlds themselves is also much easier - they're much more linear, and a useful minimap has been added. Additionally, whenever you go into a zone you've never been to yet, the name displays as ????, making it easy to tell when you're walking in circles.

Additionally, the villains of KH2 are much more interesting. Organization XIII is group of sentient nobodies, each with his or her own elemental theme, bent on universal domination and generally getting in Sora's way. They are far more interesting than Riku and Ansem were in KH1, and far more personally involved in the plot.

That said, it's not all good - while there is much less getting lost in KH2, there's really not much to explore, and I do think that the various worlds do lose something for their linearity. A compromise between the two systems would probably be ideal - though I do think that KH2's system is still overall an improvement.

The actual meta-story in KH2 is also less comprehensible than that of KH1. It's not completely opaque, but certain parts could certainly stand to be clarified. Another issue is the sheer volume of story that happens in the last world - at least to me, something like 50% of the meta-plot happens in the last 3 hours of the game. The sheer volume of plot that is thrown at you, combined with the general confusion in regards to the plot itself means that while the final fight (very epic and very fun) is entertaining, just what Xemnas's (the leader of Organization XIII, and the big bad) ultimate goals were (other than generally taking over the universe) was fairly unclear.

But overall, I think that KH2 is a big step up for KH1. A great game, and if you like games in the genre, I think you should try it out.


Things to learn specifically from KH2:

Put love into parts of sequels that need it. By learning from your mistakes, you can really put polish onto a sequel and make it fantastic. The problem is that sometimes people feel the need to change things simply for change's sake in sequels - and while it's true, a sequel that changes nothing isn't a great idea, changing things that didn't work in one game and adding things onto the things that did work is the way to do it. The way to do it is to examine the previous game (and other games in the same genre, for that matter), see what it did wrong and fix it, see what it did right and put some extra oomph into those areas. I know this sounds obvious, but too many game developers, when they make a sequel, either fail to change something that didn't work in a previous game (and it therefore continues to not work in this game), or change something that did work just fine in a previous game, taking one of the great strengths of the previous game and making it weaker. One example (though admittedly, not a modern one) of the latter is Actraiser to Actraiser 2. Actraiser was a game that had elements of both platforming and sim-city in it. Both were fairly fun, and they combined into an interesting game. Actraiser 2 cut out the sim-city aspect, and it hurt the game by changing something fundamental about it for no adequate reason.

Fun minigames can be great and welcome breaks from the main game. If done well, a recurring minigame should make you look forward to subsequent sections of it for its fun. A minigame should not overwhelm you with its depth, and it CERTAINLY shouldn't force you to dive deeply into it. A minigame has the benifit, compared to the main game, of not having to be very deep, and taking advantage of that to make a quick, fun, but ultimately shallow minigame is not a bad design idea. That said, minigame depth in general can be a tricky issue, and one that I'll look into on a later date. Lufia 2's Ancient Cave is an example of a very deep minigame done well, for example.

Saturday, March 28, 2009

Review: Kingdom Hearts

Kingdom Hearts

Kingdom Hearts is a fun action-RPG made by Square and Disney. It has, at its, core, the rather bizarre pairing of a typical Square hero with various Disney characters in a meta-plot that is typical Square that abounds with subplots that are straight out of Disney movies.

To clarify, you (Sora, the main character) and your two partners (Donald Duck and Goofy) go from one disney world to another (for example, Wonderland, Halloween Town, and Neverland), meeting up with characters from those movies, and defeating the enemies in those worlds. Meanwhile, you've got the meta-plot of trying to find your friends and save the universe. It sounds silly, and odd, but works amazingly well.

As for the gameplay, it's a third-person action game, along the lines of the Destroy All Humans! franchise, or, say, God of War. You directly control Sora, and Donald and Goofy (or whoever happens to be your allies at the time) tag along with you, acting on their own - though you can give them basic instructions as to when to use items, how often to use special attacks, etc. It's pretty good, though fairly one-dimensional - mashing x to hit people with your keyblade is often all you need to do to beat enemies, even bosses. There is magic, and it is useful, but the limited nature of it usually means that the spell you're going to be casting far more than any other is Cure, since the other magic, while useful, can simply be replaced by hitting people with your Keyblade.

You also have abilities that you can assign to your party members - special keyblade attacks, for example, or simple status or spell boosts, or new abilities like high-jumping or gliding. The customization aspect here is nice, but didn't really feel like it was all that it could be. Your choices never felt like they made that much of a difference. Still, it's something.

The enviroments also are worth noting - they are very pretty, and quite true to the movies that they are based on. However, they are huge, and often labyrinthine - you spend lots and lots of time wandering around the worlds, looking for that next place to go. Some people applaud the world design of Kingdom Hearts (at least compared to Kingdom Hearts 2), saying that the exploration of the Disney worlds was fun and cool - however, I like having a more set path to follow in my games. Exploration is all well and good, but getting lost and wandering around until you find what you need to do should be a gaming trope that no longer exists.

There's also the Gummi ship levels - levels that happen between worlds that are reminiscent of Star Fox. They're all right, but not really all that fun, at least to me. All the gummi levels felt the same, and I never really felt any incentive to play them over again. There's also gummi ship customization, which is nice, but I never really saw the draw of it, as there were no real objectives to gummi-shipping other than to get from point A to point B. The levels themselves all were very similar graphics-wise (a technicolor background with occasional rocks, rings, or other obstacles) and didn't really vary gameplay-wise either.

There's not that much more to talk about - the story is good, and very true to its sources, and the gameplay is fun, if frustrating or one-dimensional at times. Overall, a solid, fun game with a few moderately-sized flaws.

Things to learn:

Mixing atmospheres (Square and Disney) can work surprisingly well! As with Paper Mario, the idea to take away from this is that anything can work if it's done well, no matter how crazy it might sound.

Making your gameplay fast-paced is often a good thing. Fast combat is fun, more often than not, in my opinion.

Providing multiple viable options in combat makes combat more fun. Kingdom Hearts doesn't offer enough options - compare this to, say, The Force Unleashed, where you have many different viable options to kill mooks. The latter really gets quite a bit of milage out of its gameplay, whereas Kingdom Hearts really does start to wear thin towards the end in its "press x until the bad guy dies" style of gameplay.

If you're going to make transitionary levels (such as gummi ship levels), make them interesting. Don't just slap something in there to make your gameplay more diverse. You want them to be fun, good breaks that don't necessesarily need to be as deep as the main gameplay. What I'm trying to say is that these sorts of levels (and mini-games in general) should be both fun and different, not just different. It sounds obvious, but too many mini-game type things try to make things just different and forget to make them fun.

Monday, March 16, 2009

Review: Paper Mario and the Thousand-Year Door

Paper Mario: The Thousand-Year Door

A great RPG, Paper Mario: The Thousand-Year Door has you playing as Mario, as well as guest-starring Peach and Bowser. Mario faces, by and large, the X-Nauts, a group of pretty generic evil people, and their leader Grodus, who has kidnapped Peach for reasons initially unknown. Your quest is to find the seven "crystal stars," as well as rescue Princess Peach - and solve other people's problems in the meantime, too.

The story is pretty generic, but the characters really make it spring to life. Mario himself is a silent protaganist, but the other characters are fantastic - from the sexy mouse ninja Ms. Mowz to the depressed Koopa Koops, they are quite entertaining. The subplots are also quite entertaining, and often fairly original, such as when Mario looses his identity (quite literally, his name and appearance are stolen) - it's certainly enjoyable.

I feel the need to mention pacing here - most of the time, it's quite good. Dungeons and cities are laid out well (in terms of how long you spend in each), and the subplots usually last just long enough. Also, the train level towards the end was one of my favorites, and it was just a mystery with only minimal fighting for the most part. Very well done. Occasionally, however, it does falter - for example, there's one part where you have to go back and forth between the a few different areas several times - quite annoying.

Badges are how you customize Mario - you have a set number of points (that goes up as you level) to spend on badges that can give you different attacks, more health/magic, upgrade Mario's abilities... whatever you feel like. The badge system is quite well done, and an entertaining exercise in customization.

As for the combat itself, it's very entertaining. You have Mario, and his partners, one of which can be assisting you at any given time. You can switch between them on the fly (assuming you use the right badge, which I think pretty much everyone does), giving you quite a few choices for attacks. Additionally, Mario has a decent variety of attacks to choose from, depending on which badges you give him. You also have a timing element with every attack - press A when Mario lands on someone, hold left to charge the hammer - whatever. They keep combat interesting. And combat is interesting - the wide variety of things you can do with your partners and Mario, as well as the timed effects for each ability keep combat fresh and fun.

Of course, I should mention the art style - everything looks like it's made of paper. And so it is - many of the puzzles of the game involve abusing the fact that Mario is, in fact made of paper - such as folding him into a paper airplane or turning sideways to fit through a crack. Honestly, once you get used to it, the paper art style is just another part of the world. Sure, it gets used in puzzles, but really, it's just a fanciful art style that compliments the mood of the game. It never feels like it gets in the way of the game. So really, I suppose that it's done very well - it compliments the gameplay and the tone of the game, and never feels like it should have been done some other way. And this doesn't just apply to the paper-ness of everything - twilight town (or whatever it's called) and the black and white forest are both fantastic, as well as all the other locations in the game.

All in all, this is just a solid game. There are a few things I'd change, but they are only very minor points. This game deserves the high praise it gets, as it's one of the best RPG's I've played in quite some time.


Things to learn:

Adding some sort of timing to otherwise turn-based combat is a good way to keep combat interesting.

Interesting and fun characters are key. A good story is great as well, but always looking forward to what the characters will do next makes a game interesting.

Sometimes, just doing something very well without being especially innovative is excellent.

Feel free to use a seemingly bizarre art style! If you do it well, and it compliments the game, it'll work, no matter how initially crazy it may sound.



Also, some housekeeping - I've basically run out of pre-made reviews and design from my archives, so I'm shifting to a once-per-week update schedule (at least - I may update more than that), and ditching having any select day to update on - though Tuesday and/or Thursday will still be likely. Also, this is really last weeks post, so expect another later in the week.

Friday, March 6, 2009

Review: Star Wars: The Force Unleashed

Star Wars: The Force Unleashed

In this third-person action game (think something like Kingdom Hearts for gameplay, or even Mario 64) You play as the secret apprentice of Darth Vader, set between episodes 3 and 4, a force-slinging badass whose job it is, at least initially, to track down and kill the survivors of the empire's massacre of the Jedi which took place in episode 3. As is only natural for a video game, your character is actually fairly likable, and the character himself develops over time to be more of a hero, though you do have an eventual choice at the very end of the game to be good or evil. (Sort of. It's moderately complicated.) The "good" ending is actually Star Wars canon, apparently, and it's a fairly interesting tale in general.

(As a note, my review of this game comes only from the Wii version. I've never played the other versions, so anything I say here may not apply in the other versions of the game.)

The story is all well and good, and paced fairly well. The characters, as well, are fairly interesting - and of course, it helps that you already know the personalities of The Emperor and Darth Vader. It's not exactly the pinnacle of originality - especially for a Star Wars story - but it certainly gets the job done, and is certainly entertaining. Apparently, some rather important details were left out of the Wii version of this game (the rebel alliance symbol is the main characters family crest? news to me), but it still works. That said, I have no idea why this would be the case - I highly doubt it was a disk space issue, though I suppose that's not impossible. Either way, such important details shouldn't simply be cut.

But why I really love this game isn't for the story, it's for the gameplay. And let me tell you, the gameplay is fantastic. Your various force powers are, by and large, easy enough to use, as well as fairly intuitive - for example, to use "Force Push," you push the nunchuck forward. You also use the main part of the remote as a lightsaber - swinging it back and forth actually makes the main character swing his saber back and forth, in a very similar way to the way you swung the wiimote. It's really cool.

The sheer power of the main character, and the many ways you have to devastate the enemy forces, are what makes the game great. You've got your saber, you've got a few varieties of force lightning, you've got a few varieties of force push, you can throw your lightsaber (among other lightsaber-themed force powers), and you've got telekinesis, to name a few. All of them rapidly dispatch the enemy mooks, and boy is it grand. Wave after wave of enemies are sent against you, and you can dispatch them without too much difficulty in any number of entertaining ways. It's really hard to describe just how the game goes and adequetly convey the sense of fun that playing the game gives. The sheer power of the main character, the way he devastates all in his path - it's just really, really fun.

And yet, you aren't invulnerable - while you do have an innate capacity to reflect blaster shots, plenty will get through if you're not careful, and the bosses can be a pain. The balance of the main character's phenomenal cosmic powers and the game's difficulty manages to work, which is just fantastic. Enough minions (especially spread-out ones) can still do you in, and the bosses can be a pain. Which brings me to my first qualm with this game - the bosses. They all feel (at least, the humanoid ones) fairly identical, and your tactics don't really need to vary from one to another. Swing your saber, shoot some lightning, maybe try some telekinesis, and they'll eventually go down. Maybe you'll need to block from time to time, and maybe you'll have to kill some minions here or there, but the humanoid bosses (which is the majority, by the way - non-humanoid bosses are typically actually minibosses, and fairly easy in their own right) all feel basically the same.

There is also no "hard mode" in this game. Given that if you decide to start the game using your old file's data, you'll probably start with one or two maxed-out force powers, it makes the game incredibly easy until late. Additionally, there's no level select mode, which is particularly annoying given what I just said about difficulty, as well as the fact that there are many collectibles to grab throughout the levels. Trying to get all of the collectibles is quite an annoying task without any sort of level select feature. The camera could use some work as well, but it's not as bad as some I've seen.

I haven't played the multiplayer mode for this game, but I hear it's alright - though there is no online, nor are there bots you can play against. Frustrating.

The penalty for death in this game is minimal - you just lose a small amount of force points (experience used to power up your force powers), and if you're facing a boss, the boss regains a bit of health. You respawn at basically the exact same point you died at. Frankly, I think this isn't severe enough - you should get kicked back to the last checkpoint, pure and simple, and you should have a limited amount of lives before you have to restart the level. Of course, there's something to be said for being able to truck through levels, but I think with checkpoints and a fairly decent amount of lives per level, it would be a better game, since there would actually be some sense that the main character was in serious danger. Like I said earlier, the balance is good - staying alive is fairly challenging, but if you actually die, it's not that bad at all. So I suppose game balance "feels" good, but in reality, with the lack of penalty for death, it makes it a really easy game. Whenever I died in this game, I honestly felt a bit of disappointment - my thoughts were basically "Huh. Well, uh, I guess I'll go kill the dudes that killed me and move on now. And now I've got full health." Not exactly the sentiments I feel should accompany death, in pretty much any game. At the very least, the game should keep track of how many times you died, in order to make you feel bad if you die too much, and give you a "0 death run" goal to shoot for.

But all in all, this is a really great game. The gameplay is some of the funnest I've ever played, and the story is pretty good as well. I wish it was longer (it was quite easy to rent it once and beat it), but with this sort of action game, a long game isn't the standard.

Things to be learned:

Giving the main character a really high level power and tossing wave after wave of mooks at him is really, really fun if done right. Indeed, making the main character have a TON of power in general, and yet still making the game balanced, can be great fun. It's always fun to have power, and it's even better if you have incredible power and the game is still balanced. I've never encountered a game that does it as well as this one. (PS: Dear Psi-Ops, please take a look at this game. It proves that you don't have to make everything immune to your psychic powers late game in order to still have a challenge. Please take this to heart if you ever get a sequel. Love, Adam.)

Differentiate bosses. Fighting one shouldn't be the exact same thing as fight every other one.

Difficulty levels - have them. I believe this is on my "list of things games should always have." Blasting through a game with no challenge is much less fun than blasting through a game while you are being challenged.

Level select - have it. For a game like this - a game that consists of very little but one level following another following another, it's a really good feature to have.

If you can, make your multiplayer have online and computer bot capabilities. It may be some extra work, but it makes multiplayer a heck of a lot more fun.

Death should have some sort of penalty, I think. Obviously, given current games like Bioshock (or so I hear) and Destroy All Humans! that don't have a severe penalty for death, some good game designers disagree with me, and I certainly can see the reasons they choose to have a minimal penalty for death. But my (current, anyway) opinion is that there should be a decent, though certainly not unreasonable, penalty for death. I feel that this game falls into the "too small penalty for death" category.

Friday, February 27, 2009

Design: Awakenings (2)

Story thoughts:

-Before the game starts, you kill yourself for some reason, or die because of something you did. My current thought is that you get involved in a cult in life, but as you learn more about it, you disagree with their nihilist ideals. However, something happens to change your mind – perhaps your family gets killed, or something roughly as traumatic. Basically, enough to turn you initially to the dark side, but still have a believable possibility of light inside. You then decide to go through with an elaborate cult ritual which ends in your death.

-You are then, as expected, raised by your cosmic horror master, and your latent necromantic powers are awakened by him. You are told by him that you are now bound to his will, and will be his agent on earth. He needs you to free him from his bonds that keep him trapped beneath the earth, as he only has very limited influence on the events on earth from his current situation.

-Your form is that of a being made of magic. Your body and soul have been absorbed and merged by magic, rather than being any conventional sort of undead. Your appearance would be something like a multicolored (mostly dark colors), pseudocorporeal human.

-You are told by your cosmic horror master that you are simply one of many that have taken the ritual – however, this isn’t true. You are special. He only awakened your untapped necromancy potential – usually, he has to imbue the victim with some of his own power – and having done that, your power can grow greatly on its own.

-You make choose to make different moral choices as you progress, controlled by how you have your undead defeat people. Sure, at first you think that the world should be destroyed by your master, but how much pain do you need to inflict on people in the meantime? As the story progresses, you begin to question your feelings more and more as you see some goodness in humanity (at least if you are leaning towards good), and you begin to doubt your mission. Ultimately, you could choose to continue to do his will, because you like the power and like the mayhem. Or, you could choose to defy him, and make him your enemy, and ultimately redeem yourself.

-You master cannot directly see what you’re doing, but you report to him, and other, loyal cultists also report to him behind your back – thus, he can get some sense of whether you’re lying to him or not, but can’t know for sure.

-The gameplay is changed somewhat by how you choose to play morally. First, you can still have your undead fight with you, but you have to tell them to disable, not kill, your enemies – they deal slightly less damage this way, and you don’t get very many resources from the bodies, however, you also attract less attention from other enemies (For example, if this was GTA, your star rating would go up less) – and thus you have to fight less enemies. Certain undead might have certain moves that make this easier than others – creatures that can shock enemies into unconsciousness, for example. You also have undead that can be stealthy, and favoring them could make going “good” easier.

-As you progress in the story, in addition to changing the way that you play the game somewhat, the story also begins to change as you make your choices. You do missions in different ways, obviously, but you can also choose to do different missions – if you want to destroy your master, you can do a quest to get more information from a former cult site in some mountains, for example, which in turn leads to a hunt for an artifact to destroy him. If you want to simply release him, as he’d like, you have to collect a different artifact to complete the relic that could free him. If you want to destroy him and absorb his power, then you could do a mix of the two, but neither would require quite as much effort – the idea is for all four paths to be roughly the same difficulty. If you want to prevent his raising but not take the risk of trying to destroy him, then you hunt down what would be used to raise him and hide it better or try to destroy it.

-Obviously, you can harvest your resources from people, but you can also get corpses and souls from graveyards and the like (morgues?) The alternate resources, such as plants and magical stone, could also be harvested in other, murder-neutral ways.


-Using souls isn’t as evil as it initially sounds. Souls outside of bodies can’t be destroyed, and are by default unconscious in this world – they usually only remain in the world for a short time after their body’s death by default, though they can persist for some time, especially near graveyards and the like. Thus, while you do keep them from going on to the afterlife with your magic, they are not conscious for it, and if they “fall” in your service, the magic binding them releases, and they depart to the afterlife.

-You have to recover some mysterious artifact in order to free your master, the pieces to which are scattered around the world.

-A mysterious (and ultimately very powerful, though that part is hidden) counter/foil to the cosmic horror appears (perhaps a love-interestish female?), and tries to draw you back into the light, or at least, to deny your master. He or she probably appears at the end of certain missions, at least to start with, and just points out the goodness of humanity to you and the like. S/he is the agent of some other force, and in the end, you accept that person’s ideas, or you kill (or at least reject) him or her.

Possible endings:
- You summon forth your horror master to take over the world, as its servant. You become absorbed into its being, and it does its stuff. World ends, everyone dies – or something like that. Final Boss: Mysterious other character.
- You summon forth your master, in order to destroy it. You do so, and save the world. Possibly involving a heroic sacrifice. Final Boss: Cosmic Horror
- You re-seal (or don’t unseal, and perhaps make it harder for the next guy to try to unseal) the monster, so it remains, but so do you, at least in theory. Final Boss: Mysterious other character
- You summon forth your master in order to destroy it, and take its place. Final Boss: Cosmic Horror