Showing posts with label Review. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Review. Show all posts

Thursday, July 5, 2012

Review: Kid Icarus: Uprising

Kid Icarus: Uprising

Kid Icarus: Uprising is an action game that was released a few months ago on the 3DS, and it very quickly became one of my favorite games. It simply has a ton of content, and its basic gameplay mechanics are quite a lot of fun. Add on a relatively solid online multiplayer, you have a real winner. Of course, it's still not without flaws - the online multiplayer isn't as good as it could be, and the controls, while usable, are difficult to use.

First of all, the single-player content is extremely extensive. There are twenty-five levels, most of which consist of one aerial, star-fox ish part, and a ground part which isn't as easily comparable to any other game, but kind of resembles God of War - the closest analogy I can think of is a 3-d Mega Man X. Regardless, both gameplay styles are fairly fast-paced, and both are pretty solid. The controls for the ground section are a bit dodgy, though - aiming and shooting without two joysticks, or a keyboard and mouse, takes some getting used to. Also, holding the 3DS in such a way as to use the controls (and not being extremely uncomfortable after a few minutes), while definitely possible, requires the use of a non-standard grip or using the 3DS stand that came with the game. Personally, I don't really know how they could have improved the controls. They definitely put a lot of effort into making them customizable, and clearly tried to make it work (thus the stand). But they're still awkward, regardless.

But anyway, the actual replayability for the single-player game comes from three things - forging custom weapons (along with collecting weapons and powers), the difficulty slider increasing the difficulty of any level to an extremely high level, and the achievement system. Forging custom weapons typically requires a fair bit of farming to collect weapons with properties, and then finding a way to combine them into something that you want. Fusion is very fickle, though, and to get a weapon with *exactly* what you want, you'll need to do a *lot* of farming. Personally, I generally like how they did it, but I feel that some greater degree of control over the final product would be very helpful. It is almost entirely out of the player's control if a weapon fusion results in anything usable or not, and while that does add replayability, it also really hurts usability. Also, power collection is quite uncontrollable as well - some way to exert some sort of control over the powers you collect would be very helpful.

The difficulty slider in this game is one of my favorite in any game I've ever seen. The difficulty goes from completely trivial (0.0) to brutally difficult (9.0), and everywhere in between. They really nailed it here. The difficulty scale primarily controls how much damage the enemies do, how much health they have, how fast (and how homing) their bullets are, how often they shoot, and how fast they are. Sadly, it very rarely (if ever) changes any abilities that enemies have, and it almost never adds any new ones. It also only rarely increases the number of enemies that spawn. Still, the changes that are there change the game enough to make it a very different experience when you jump up 2 or more full numbers in difficulty. Honestly, I would change extremely little about the difficulty slider. I will say that the bosses have (far) too little health on anything but the highest difficulties, so I'd increase that, and I would probably add a new ability to each boss if they were played on 9.0 difficulty. Still, those are relatively minor changes to a very good system.

Lastly, the achievement system. It's pretty typical stuff, and encourages you to play in ways that you normally wouldn't, making the game more interesting, and rewarding you for your accomplishments. I'd change one or two things about it - one, the trophies (idols, technically) that you receive through achievements can still be found other ways, which I think is silly - they should be exclusive, in order to be more significant rewards - especially the ones that you get by accomplishing some of the most difficult tasks in the game, like boss battles on hard - perhaps the single hardest thing to do in the game, and your only tangible reward for it is a trophy that you're almost guaranteed to already have at that point. Secondly, I'd get rid of the achievements that more or less amount to "Run through this level on 0.0 using a certain weapon." They're not hard, they're not particularly exciting, and I don't think that they really add anything other than a bit of mindless replayability. Don't get me wrong, I was having enough fun with the game that I did them anyway, but there was definitely room for improvement with them.

And, of course, there's the online multiplayer. Fast-paced, fun, with a solid degree of customization - the gameplay itself is great. However, it really suffers from the lack of any sort of ranking system - meaning that without hunting down people to add to your friends list, the level of challenge the online multiplayer gives will vary greatly from game to game. Additionally, a few more modes would have been nice - FFA and Team Vs are nice, but adding in some sort of co-op, ideally in the form of a horde mode, for example, would have been amazing. What's particularly frustrating is that there is a level in the game that is, more or less, a horde mode, and you even do it co-op with a computer-controlled ally. I really surprised that they would have something like that in the game, but then not make the obvious leap to putting it into multiplayer.

In regards to the online ranking system, though, I have one theory as to why they didn't add it - because the game, I think, is not very balanced, and thus the online multiplayer could devolve into using one of a handful of broken strategies (and not always fun ones - extreme homing shots coming through wall, invisible, invincible snipers, etc), or just dying. If this was the case, and there was then an intentional design decision to not put a ranking system in, then I do respect that decision, but I still disagree with it. Even if online multiplayer at high skill/gear levels wasn't very balanced, I still think that having both a ranked and unranked system would be preferable to the current system. I personally (though I haven't tested the system extensively) don't think that the ranked multiplayer at high levels would be too incredibly overcentralized to suck the fun out of the game, and even though there would be less people in unranked multiplayer if there was a ranked option, I think there would be enough that it would be a viable alternative to playing ranked if you didn't want to deal with ranked shenanigans.

Overall, I really enjoyed this game. But it does have its issues, as I've detailed, and I think that it could have been a noticeably better game with a few changes. Here's what I feel I learned from this game:

-Having a *good* difficulty slider (and ideally, a gear system to support it) adds a great deal of replayability to a game.
-Online multiplayer needs a ranked option in order to remain fun over the long-term for anyone that doesn't feel like seeking out people to play with on the internet.
-More multiplayer modes, more better. Having some sort of PvE cooperative multiplayer that emulates the single-player game could be a good way to get people to transition from single-player to multi-player.

Sunday, February 26, 2012

Review: Skyrim

So often I review cool but obscure games, this time I thought I'd take on something a little more mainstream.

The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim is, for those of you living under a rock, an action-RPG that was released for the PC, Xbox 360, and PS3. I played it on the PS3 (and am still technically playing it there, as I never did finish everything I wanted to, but who does in this game), and first of all, I'd like to say that I had a ton of fun with it. The biggest draw of Skyrim, and the Elder Scrolls series in general, is the gigantic fantasy world sandbox of things to do. Coming up right below the world is the different ways you can customize your character - rather than a class, in this game, you can pick and choose from many different talent trees, and thus create a unique playstyle that fits you.

The game's huge world has so much to do, it's extremely easy to be drawn off track by something interesting - and indeed, I'd argue that that is the whole point of the game. Getting from point A to point B becomes something else entirely when you pass 8 dungeons along the way that you can clear out and loot - often finding something tied to a bigger quest there. The scope of the game is simply incredible, both in terms of the number of things to do and each of these things remains interesting.

With that said, the game has numerous faults. The two biggest problems with this game are bugs and balance. The game is simply inexcusably buggy, even 3+ months after being released. Companions don't level to your character properly. Quests can bug out and become incompletable, preventing progress in fairly major ways. Companions can become stuck in certain zones of the game, meaning that you lose access to them forever - particularly fun if you've also married them. This is to say nothing of the lag issues that plagued the PS3 version until the most recent patch. I understand that a game this large is going to have some bugs, but there is a difference between some bugs and what Skyrim has, especially what it shipped with.

The "balance," such as it is, is also something of a joke. At least in my experience, I had to actively refrain from doing activities I otherwise would have in order to keep the game moderately challenging. Indeed, I'm using what is considered to be one of the weaker playstyles, blaster mage, and on master difficulty I'm still finding the game to be pretty darn easy. And it's simply the easiest thing in the world to ruin the game's balance for yourself by leveling up smithing or enchanting particularly early on (especially smithing - or, god forbid, both). Conjuration is also ridiculously powerful if powerleveled, as I understand it, and in general I'm given to believe that bow-using stealth characters are a particularly broken archetype. Vampire illusionists, from what I understand, can render every single enemy in the game except for dragons completely harmless. And dragons in general are surprisingly anticlimatic fights. Again, in a game this large and characters this customizable, there are bound to be issues, but Skyrim kicks it up a few notches above that.

But, as I said, I did really enjoy the game. I just think that it could have used a lot more time on bug-fixing and balancing.

Some of the lessons I've learned from this game are:
-Having a very customizable character is indeed great. I mentioned the idea in one of my earlier posts, regarding the ability to create your own class for an RPG, but this game takes that and really runs with it.
-Open worlds, as long as they don't feel empty, can make games all by themselves. Throw in enough decently interesting quests here and there, make the many dungeons each at least a little bit unique, and you've got a really fun game pretty much ready to go.

However, I also learned a few more lessons from this game. These lessons I hope that I am never reduced to using:
-A game can incredibly buggy and still ship to great reviews if it is fun enough. In particular, an open world game with lots of content, so that you can at least theoretically avoid the bugs, lends itself to this particularly well.
-Game balance, at least in single player games, can be almost tossed out the window in favor of other aspects of the game, especially at higher levels.

Tuesday, April 13, 2010

Review: Ace Attorney Investigations: Miles Edgeworth

Ace Attorney Investigations: Miles Edgeworth is the latest game in the Ace Attorney series; a very amusing series of adventure games in which you play an anime-style defense attorney in search of the truth, which consists of both searching for clues in crime scenes as well as defending your clients in court. In this game, however, there is no court aspect; despite the fact that they mixed things up by have you play as the prosecutor from the first 3 games, Miles Edgeworth, you do not actually do any prosecuting. Instead, you simply investigate crime scenes and confront the criminals. This is my first complaint about the game - if a prosecutor is the star, then he should be prosecuting, not doing detective work.

In another change from the standard Ace Attorney gameplay, the investigation parts of the game are conducted from a third-person view, rather than a first-person view. This, I believe, was a good choice - it makes the game feel a little more open, which is something that previous Ace Attorney games lacked. However, it also removed the ability to move freely between areas, which I think was a poor move - when you're investigating an area, that's really the only area you can go to, and you very rarely have to move between areas in the middle of an investigation, though you may after talking to someone to get new information.

The interrogation/rebuttal portions of the game, where you accuse potential criminals or are generally trying to get more information out of people are basically the exact same as they were in previous games - you go through a series of statements, have the option to get more information about each statement, and when you see a contradiction between your evidence and the statement, you present your evidence to point out that contradiction and to advance the game. It's not a bad system, but it's basically unchanged since the first Ace Attorney game, and still occasionally has moments of unintuitiveness.

This game also included a "Logic Mode," which I really enjoyed - Miles Edgeworth is a lot more methodical and less slapdash than the usual main character, Phoenix Wright, for whom a logic mode would not have been in character. However, one of my complaints is that what became a piece of evidence and what became a bit of logic felt quite arbitrary - some integration between logic mode and your evidence would have been nice.

But the real reason to play Ace Attorney games is for the characters, who are universally entertaining, and often hilarious; as well as for the plot. The characters in this game definitely didn't disappoint - Edgeworth was his usual stoic, straight-man self, detective gumshoe was as lovably unhelpful as ever, and all the other characters filled their roles quite well. The plot of the various cases (and overarching plot) was quite entertaining as well. There were, of course, a few hiccups - the final confrontation with the main villain at the end dragged on for ages, for example. But in general, it was very well done.

All in all a good game, but not without its flaws.

Things to learn:
-Don't change things for the sake of change if something works.
-That said, don't allow something to remain stagnant over the course of 5 games.
-Entertaining characters and an intriguing plot can compensate for "eh" gameplay; similarly, gameplay can be relatively simplistic and still end up with an entertaining game.
-Giving hints to solve puzzles, especially puzzles of the "look everywhere until you find something" variety, is a good idea, at least if a player appears stuck.
-Make sure any logic that you require the player to use is sound.
-If the main character has a profession, make sure that he actually uses, especially in a story-centric game.

Wednesday, July 1, 2009

Review: Kingdom Hearts 2

And here, after a long break, is my review for Kingdom Hearts 2.

KH2 is, unsurprisingly, very similar to KH1. The main character is (usually) the same, the supporting characters are the same, the gameplay is quite similar. The story is fairly similar as well, as least in terms of traveling from one disney world to another in order to defeat the heartless (or nobodies now, occasionally).

However, KH2 is, by and large, much more polished than the first game. First, and most obviously, the Gummi Ship levels - transition levels between larger disney worlds - are leaps and bounds above the gummi ship levels in KH1. They are no longer all drug-trip themed, the enemies you face are diverse, the gummi ship builder is more helpful and intuitive, and the rewards for doing the levels are much more... rewarding. The levels themselves are all very pretty, and very fast-paced - as it should be with a space-shooter, at least usually. All in all, the whole gummi ship system was revamped, and it shows. It's very, very fun in ways that the original wasn't - it now feels like something that design and testing time went into, and they didn't just shove it onto the main game to have something different in the main game - it is now fun, and not just different.

There are many changes within the main game as well. The combat is still largely the same (mash attack until the bad guy dies), but it has several new and shiny features. First among them is probably the "reaction command" system. Basically, every now and then, a "reaction command" will pop up - the game gives you an interesting combat option if you press triangle. These vary greatly, as anything from 'dodge' to 'grab the axe he dropped and smack him with it.' They do add depth to the system, but they can be ignored most of the time - they do make life easier for you if you do use them, though. I'm not in love with the system, though - it feels kind of limited, like they could've done some of these commands without sticking them onto a whole seperate system.

Secondarily, the magic system has been revamped. All spells other than cure cost a fixed amount of mana, and cure immediately drains all of your mana. Once your mana bar is empty, it automatically refills over a period of time. The end result of this is the opposite of what is the case in KH1 - there, every spell you cast that wasn't cure was largely a waste of mana. Here, spamming other spells is encouraged, because cure, while still the most useful spell in your arsenal, does not have a fixed cost, but simply drains all your mana. Thus, it doesn't matter how much mana you have left when you do finally cast it. It's quite a good system, I think - far better than KH1's system, anyway. The best spell is no longer the only spell you should ever cast.

A few more improvements have been made to the gameplay - one major one is the idea of forms. You can combine Sora with one or both of your party members in order gain a temporary power boost. It's quite nifty, actually - the forms are very fun, and a good addition to a varying arsenal of means of killing your enemies. It's like Star Wars: Force Unleashed - having a vast number of ways to kill your enemies makes random encounters much more interesting.

Navigating the worlds themselves is also much easier - they're much more linear, and a useful minimap has been added. Additionally, whenever you go into a zone you've never been to yet, the name displays as ????, making it easy to tell when you're walking in circles.

Additionally, the villains of KH2 are much more interesting. Organization XIII is group of sentient nobodies, each with his or her own elemental theme, bent on universal domination and generally getting in Sora's way. They are far more interesting than Riku and Ansem were in KH1, and far more personally involved in the plot.

That said, it's not all good - while there is much less getting lost in KH2, there's really not much to explore, and I do think that the various worlds do lose something for their linearity. A compromise between the two systems would probably be ideal - though I do think that KH2's system is still overall an improvement.

The actual meta-story in KH2 is also less comprehensible than that of KH1. It's not completely opaque, but certain parts could certainly stand to be clarified. Another issue is the sheer volume of story that happens in the last world - at least to me, something like 50% of the meta-plot happens in the last 3 hours of the game. The sheer volume of plot that is thrown at you, combined with the general confusion in regards to the plot itself means that while the final fight (very epic and very fun) is entertaining, just what Xemnas's (the leader of Organization XIII, and the big bad) ultimate goals were (other than generally taking over the universe) was fairly unclear.

But overall, I think that KH2 is a big step up for KH1. A great game, and if you like games in the genre, I think you should try it out.


Things to learn specifically from KH2:

Put love into parts of sequels that need it. By learning from your mistakes, you can really put polish onto a sequel and make it fantastic. The problem is that sometimes people feel the need to change things simply for change's sake in sequels - and while it's true, a sequel that changes nothing isn't a great idea, changing things that didn't work in one game and adding things onto the things that did work is the way to do it. The way to do it is to examine the previous game (and other games in the same genre, for that matter), see what it did wrong and fix it, see what it did right and put some extra oomph into those areas. I know this sounds obvious, but too many game developers, when they make a sequel, either fail to change something that didn't work in a previous game (and it therefore continues to not work in this game), or change something that did work just fine in a previous game, taking one of the great strengths of the previous game and making it weaker. One example (though admittedly, not a modern one) of the latter is Actraiser to Actraiser 2. Actraiser was a game that had elements of both platforming and sim-city in it. Both were fairly fun, and they combined into an interesting game. Actraiser 2 cut out the sim-city aspect, and it hurt the game by changing something fundamental about it for no adequate reason.

Fun minigames can be great and welcome breaks from the main game. If done well, a recurring minigame should make you look forward to subsequent sections of it for its fun. A minigame should not overwhelm you with its depth, and it CERTAINLY shouldn't force you to dive deeply into it. A minigame has the benifit, compared to the main game, of not having to be very deep, and taking advantage of that to make a quick, fun, but ultimately shallow minigame is not a bad design idea. That said, minigame depth in general can be a tricky issue, and one that I'll look into on a later date. Lufia 2's Ancient Cave is an example of a very deep minigame done well, for example.

Saturday, March 28, 2009

Review: Kingdom Hearts

Kingdom Hearts

Kingdom Hearts is a fun action-RPG made by Square and Disney. It has, at its, core, the rather bizarre pairing of a typical Square hero with various Disney characters in a meta-plot that is typical Square that abounds with subplots that are straight out of Disney movies.

To clarify, you (Sora, the main character) and your two partners (Donald Duck and Goofy) go from one disney world to another (for example, Wonderland, Halloween Town, and Neverland), meeting up with characters from those movies, and defeating the enemies in those worlds. Meanwhile, you've got the meta-plot of trying to find your friends and save the universe. It sounds silly, and odd, but works amazingly well.

As for the gameplay, it's a third-person action game, along the lines of the Destroy All Humans! franchise, or, say, God of War. You directly control Sora, and Donald and Goofy (or whoever happens to be your allies at the time) tag along with you, acting on their own - though you can give them basic instructions as to when to use items, how often to use special attacks, etc. It's pretty good, though fairly one-dimensional - mashing x to hit people with your keyblade is often all you need to do to beat enemies, even bosses. There is magic, and it is useful, but the limited nature of it usually means that the spell you're going to be casting far more than any other is Cure, since the other magic, while useful, can simply be replaced by hitting people with your Keyblade.

You also have abilities that you can assign to your party members - special keyblade attacks, for example, or simple status or spell boosts, or new abilities like high-jumping or gliding. The customization aspect here is nice, but didn't really feel like it was all that it could be. Your choices never felt like they made that much of a difference. Still, it's something.

The enviroments also are worth noting - they are very pretty, and quite true to the movies that they are based on. However, they are huge, and often labyrinthine - you spend lots and lots of time wandering around the worlds, looking for that next place to go. Some people applaud the world design of Kingdom Hearts (at least compared to Kingdom Hearts 2), saying that the exploration of the Disney worlds was fun and cool - however, I like having a more set path to follow in my games. Exploration is all well and good, but getting lost and wandering around until you find what you need to do should be a gaming trope that no longer exists.

There's also the Gummi ship levels - levels that happen between worlds that are reminiscent of Star Fox. They're all right, but not really all that fun, at least to me. All the gummi levels felt the same, and I never really felt any incentive to play them over again. There's also gummi ship customization, which is nice, but I never really saw the draw of it, as there were no real objectives to gummi-shipping other than to get from point A to point B. The levels themselves all were very similar graphics-wise (a technicolor background with occasional rocks, rings, or other obstacles) and didn't really vary gameplay-wise either.

There's not that much more to talk about - the story is good, and very true to its sources, and the gameplay is fun, if frustrating or one-dimensional at times. Overall, a solid, fun game with a few moderately-sized flaws.

Things to learn:

Mixing atmospheres (Square and Disney) can work surprisingly well! As with Paper Mario, the idea to take away from this is that anything can work if it's done well, no matter how crazy it might sound.

Making your gameplay fast-paced is often a good thing. Fast combat is fun, more often than not, in my opinion.

Providing multiple viable options in combat makes combat more fun. Kingdom Hearts doesn't offer enough options - compare this to, say, The Force Unleashed, where you have many different viable options to kill mooks. The latter really gets quite a bit of milage out of its gameplay, whereas Kingdom Hearts really does start to wear thin towards the end in its "press x until the bad guy dies" style of gameplay.

If you're going to make transitionary levels (such as gummi ship levels), make them interesting. Don't just slap something in there to make your gameplay more diverse. You want them to be fun, good breaks that don't necessesarily need to be as deep as the main gameplay. What I'm trying to say is that these sorts of levels (and mini-games in general) should be both fun and different, not just different. It sounds obvious, but too many mini-game type things try to make things just different and forget to make them fun.

Monday, March 16, 2009

Review: Paper Mario and the Thousand-Year Door

Paper Mario: The Thousand-Year Door

A great RPG, Paper Mario: The Thousand-Year Door has you playing as Mario, as well as guest-starring Peach and Bowser. Mario faces, by and large, the X-Nauts, a group of pretty generic evil people, and their leader Grodus, who has kidnapped Peach for reasons initially unknown. Your quest is to find the seven "crystal stars," as well as rescue Princess Peach - and solve other people's problems in the meantime, too.

The story is pretty generic, but the characters really make it spring to life. Mario himself is a silent protaganist, but the other characters are fantastic - from the sexy mouse ninja Ms. Mowz to the depressed Koopa Koops, they are quite entertaining. The subplots are also quite entertaining, and often fairly original, such as when Mario looses his identity (quite literally, his name and appearance are stolen) - it's certainly enjoyable.

I feel the need to mention pacing here - most of the time, it's quite good. Dungeons and cities are laid out well (in terms of how long you spend in each), and the subplots usually last just long enough. Also, the train level towards the end was one of my favorites, and it was just a mystery with only minimal fighting for the most part. Very well done. Occasionally, however, it does falter - for example, there's one part where you have to go back and forth between the a few different areas several times - quite annoying.

Badges are how you customize Mario - you have a set number of points (that goes up as you level) to spend on badges that can give you different attacks, more health/magic, upgrade Mario's abilities... whatever you feel like. The badge system is quite well done, and an entertaining exercise in customization.

As for the combat itself, it's very entertaining. You have Mario, and his partners, one of which can be assisting you at any given time. You can switch between them on the fly (assuming you use the right badge, which I think pretty much everyone does), giving you quite a few choices for attacks. Additionally, Mario has a decent variety of attacks to choose from, depending on which badges you give him. You also have a timing element with every attack - press A when Mario lands on someone, hold left to charge the hammer - whatever. They keep combat interesting. And combat is interesting - the wide variety of things you can do with your partners and Mario, as well as the timed effects for each ability keep combat fresh and fun.

Of course, I should mention the art style - everything looks like it's made of paper. And so it is - many of the puzzles of the game involve abusing the fact that Mario is, in fact made of paper - such as folding him into a paper airplane or turning sideways to fit through a crack. Honestly, once you get used to it, the paper art style is just another part of the world. Sure, it gets used in puzzles, but really, it's just a fanciful art style that compliments the mood of the game. It never feels like it gets in the way of the game. So really, I suppose that it's done very well - it compliments the gameplay and the tone of the game, and never feels like it should have been done some other way. And this doesn't just apply to the paper-ness of everything - twilight town (or whatever it's called) and the black and white forest are both fantastic, as well as all the other locations in the game.

All in all, this is just a solid game. There are a few things I'd change, but they are only very minor points. This game deserves the high praise it gets, as it's one of the best RPG's I've played in quite some time.


Things to learn:

Adding some sort of timing to otherwise turn-based combat is a good way to keep combat interesting.

Interesting and fun characters are key. A good story is great as well, but always looking forward to what the characters will do next makes a game interesting.

Sometimes, just doing something very well without being especially innovative is excellent.

Feel free to use a seemingly bizarre art style! If you do it well, and it compliments the game, it'll work, no matter how initially crazy it may sound.



Also, some housekeeping - I've basically run out of pre-made reviews and design from my archives, so I'm shifting to a once-per-week update schedule (at least - I may update more than that), and ditching having any select day to update on - though Tuesday and/or Thursday will still be likely. Also, this is really last weeks post, so expect another later in the week.

Friday, March 6, 2009

Review: Star Wars: The Force Unleashed

Star Wars: The Force Unleashed

In this third-person action game (think something like Kingdom Hearts for gameplay, or even Mario 64) You play as the secret apprentice of Darth Vader, set between episodes 3 and 4, a force-slinging badass whose job it is, at least initially, to track down and kill the survivors of the empire's massacre of the Jedi which took place in episode 3. As is only natural for a video game, your character is actually fairly likable, and the character himself develops over time to be more of a hero, though you do have an eventual choice at the very end of the game to be good or evil. (Sort of. It's moderately complicated.) The "good" ending is actually Star Wars canon, apparently, and it's a fairly interesting tale in general.

(As a note, my review of this game comes only from the Wii version. I've never played the other versions, so anything I say here may not apply in the other versions of the game.)

The story is all well and good, and paced fairly well. The characters, as well, are fairly interesting - and of course, it helps that you already know the personalities of The Emperor and Darth Vader. It's not exactly the pinnacle of originality - especially for a Star Wars story - but it certainly gets the job done, and is certainly entertaining. Apparently, some rather important details were left out of the Wii version of this game (the rebel alliance symbol is the main characters family crest? news to me), but it still works. That said, I have no idea why this would be the case - I highly doubt it was a disk space issue, though I suppose that's not impossible. Either way, such important details shouldn't simply be cut.

But why I really love this game isn't for the story, it's for the gameplay. And let me tell you, the gameplay is fantastic. Your various force powers are, by and large, easy enough to use, as well as fairly intuitive - for example, to use "Force Push," you push the nunchuck forward. You also use the main part of the remote as a lightsaber - swinging it back and forth actually makes the main character swing his saber back and forth, in a very similar way to the way you swung the wiimote. It's really cool.

The sheer power of the main character, and the many ways you have to devastate the enemy forces, are what makes the game great. You've got your saber, you've got a few varieties of force lightning, you've got a few varieties of force push, you can throw your lightsaber (among other lightsaber-themed force powers), and you've got telekinesis, to name a few. All of them rapidly dispatch the enemy mooks, and boy is it grand. Wave after wave of enemies are sent against you, and you can dispatch them without too much difficulty in any number of entertaining ways. It's really hard to describe just how the game goes and adequetly convey the sense of fun that playing the game gives. The sheer power of the main character, the way he devastates all in his path - it's just really, really fun.

And yet, you aren't invulnerable - while you do have an innate capacity to reflect blaster shots, plenty will get through if you're not careful, and the bosses can be a pain. The balance of the main character's phenomenal cosmic powers and the game's difficulty manages to work, which is just fantastic. Enough minions (especially spread-out ones) can still do you in, and the bosses can be a pain. Which brings me to my first qualm with this game - the bosses. They all feel (at least, the humanoid ones) fairly identical, and your tactics don't really need to vary from one to another. Swing your saber, shoot some lightning, maybe try some telekinesis, and they'll eventually go down. Maybe you'll need to block from time to time, and maybe you'll have to kill some minions here or there, but the humanoid bosses (which is the majority, by the way - non-humanoid bosses are typically actually minibosses, and fairly easy in their own right) all feel basically the same.

There is also no "hard mode" in this game. Given that if you decide to start the game using your old file's data, you'll probably start with one or two maxed-out force powers, it makes the game incredibly easy until late. Additionally, there's no level select mode, which is particularly annoying given what I just said about difficulty, as well as the fact that there are many collectibles to grab throughout the levels. Trying to get all of the collectibles is quite an annoying task without any sort of level select feature. The camera could use some work as well, but it's not as bad as some I've seen.

I haven't played the multiplayer mode for this game, but I hear it's alright - though there is no online, nor are there bots you can play against. Frustrating.

The penalty for death in this game is minimal - you just lose a small amount of force points (experience used to power up your force powers), and if you're facing a boss, the boss regains a bit of health. You respawn at basically the exact same point you died at. Frankly, I think this isn't severe enough - you should get kicked back to the last checkpoint, pure and simple, and you should have a limited amount of lives before you have to restart the level. Of course, there's something to be said for being able to truck through levels, but I think with checkpoints and a fairly decent amount of lives per level, it would be a better game, since there would actually be some sense that the main character was in serious danger. Like I said earlier, the balance is good - staying alive is fairly challenging, but if you actually die, it's not that bad at all. So I suppose game balance "feels" good, but in reality, with the lack of penalty for death, it makes it a really easy game. Whenever I died in this game, I honestly felt a bit of disappointment - my thoughts were basically "Huh. Well, uh, I guess I'll go kill the dudes that killed me and move on now. And now I've got full health." Not exactly the sentiments I feel should accompany death, in pretty much any game. At the very least, the game should keep track of how many times you died, in order to make you feel bad if you die too much, and give you a "0 death run" goal to shoot for.

But all in all, this is a really great game. The gameplay is some of the funnest I've ever played, and the story is pretty good as well. I wish it was longer (it was quite easy to rent it once and beat it), but with this sort of action game, a long game isn't the standard.

Things to be learned:

Giving the main character a really high level power and tossing wave after wave of mooks at him is really, really fun if done right. Indeed, making the main character have a TON of power in general, and yet still making the game balanced, can be great fun. It's always fun to have power, and it's even better if you have incredible power and the game is still balanced. I've never encountered a game that does it as well as this one. (PS: Dear Psi-Ops, please take a look at this game. It proves that you don't have to make everything immune to your psychic powers late game in order to still have a challenge. Please take this to heart if you ever get a sequel. Love, Adam.)

Differentiate bosses. Fighting one shouldn't be the exact same thing as fight every other one.

Difficulty levels - have them. I believe this is on my "list of things games should always have." Blasting through a game with no challenge is much less fun than blasting through a game while you are being challenged.

Level select - have it. For a game like this - a game that consists of very little but one level following another following another, it's a really good feature to have.

If you can, make your multiplayer have online and computer bot capabilities. It may be some extra work, but it makes multiplayer a heck of a lot more fun.

Death should have some sort of penalty, I think. Obviously, given current games like Bioshock (or so I hear) and Destroy All Humans! that don't have a severe penalty for death, some good game designers disagree with me, and I certainly can see the reasons they choose to have a minimal penalty for death. But my (current, anyway) opinion is that there should be a decent, though certainly not unreasonable, penalty for death. I feel that this game falls into the "too small penalty for death" category.

Wednesday, February 18, 2009

Review: World of Warcraft Karazhan Boss Reviews

I did some reviews of Karazhan bosses in WoW, a while back. Just to note some things about MMO boss design, MMO design, and game design in general. Here's what I wrote:

Romulo and Julienne

Summary: One of three possible bosses summoned during the Opera event in Karazhan. Julienne comes out first, followed by Romulo, then both. Both have self-buffs that must be dispelled. Julienne is primarily a caster, Romulo is physical. When you fight both at once, they must be killed within 10 seconds of each other.

Good Points: The ability to spellsteal Julienne’s buff for great effect is nice, as opposed to simply dispelling it. Also, Julienne and Romulo are well designed in that only one of them screws up melee, so it naturally divides the raid into who’s attacking who.

Bad Points:

Neutral Points: The progressive nature of the fight.

Tank: Tank one, and/or the other. Quite basic, really.

Ranged DPS: DPS one or the other. Spellsteal Julienne’s buff.

Melee DPS: DPS primarily Julienne.

Healers: Heal tanks and whoever’s getting hit by Julienne’s spells. Dispel their buffs.

Raid Leader: Coordinate DPS between Romulo and Julienne.

Lessons Learned: Again, pulling out pseudo-obscure abilities is good. Makes people remember every spell they have. Dividing the raid can also prove entertaining.

How I would change the fight: Make them both somewhat harder individually. Make them both rez at less than 100% health during the final part of the fight, and whenever you kill one of them, the other one kills him/herself. Shakespeare at its finest.


The Wizard of Oz

Summary: One of three possible bosses summoned during the Opera event in Karazhan. The fight starts by introducing, one by one, the members of the fight: Dorothee (who summons Tito), Strawman, Tinhead, and Roar. Strawman, Tinhead, and Roar each have a weakness based on the movie: Strawman is disoriented by fire, Tinhead becomes slower and slower, and Roar can be feared. After this, you fight the Crone.

Good Points: The fight is very funny. The weaknesses of Dorothee’s companions are quite amusing, and logical. Also the fight demands things of people outside their standard roles.

Bad Points:

Neutral Points: The Crone is very easy. If you get to her, you’ve basically won.

Tank: Tank/kite Tinhead, distract Strawman and/or Roar, and offtank Tito.

Ranged DPS: DPS them in order, while fearing Roar and using fire on Strawman, and avoiding Tinhead.

Melee DPS: DPS them in order, avoiding Tinhead.

Healers: Healing on whoever needs it.

Raid Leader: Decide the order in which to DPS them down, and who should control who.

Lessons Learned: Cluster fights can work, and can be quite entertaining. Quirky but logical weaknesses are also fun.

How I’d change the fight: Make the Crone a little harder.




The Curator

Summary: The first fight of the “second half” of Karazhan (or perhaps the last fight of the first half), the curator has several abilities. The first is his sparks, which are summoned every 10 seconds, and must be killed, ideally before the next one is summoned. The second is Hateful Bolt, an arcane bolt that he shoots at whoever is second on his threat list. Last is his evocation, which he does after every tenth spark. He stops doing anything and regains the mana he lost summoning the sparks. While doing this for twenty seconds, he takes triple damage.

Good Points: Tank and Spank with a very interesting twist. The sparks force the DPS to do something other than just sit there and throw spells/attacks at the curator, and the evocations are a natural time to switch to the curator. Also, there’s several ways to deal with the Hateful Bolts.

Bad Points:

Neutral Points: Tank does very little.

Tank: Just tank the Curator. One tank may also be attempting to corral the sparks.

Ranged DPS: DPS the sparks, and then the Curator. One ranged DPS may be “tanking” the Hateful Bolts.

Melee DPS: DPS the sparks and Curator. One may be attempting to corral the sparks.

Healers: Heal the tank, the hateful bolt tank, and whoever gets hit by the sparks.

Raid Leader: Figure out how to deal with the bolts and the sparks.

Lessons Learned: While somewhat complicated, the curator is very much the bridge between the first and second halves of Karazhan. He is a well-designed fight for this, testing all aspects of your raid (save for the main tank, unfortunately).

How I would change the fight: Make it test the main tank somehow. I’d say some sort of spell reflection timing, but that would make it warrior-exclusive. Perhaps making the tank move him constantly, or move him only at certain times. At 50% mana, perhaps, the tank has to move out. Something.




Just three sample reviews. I do like the fights, obviously: I think WoW is a very well designed game, and the bosses are great. I do have some small quibbles with choices made by the designers occasionally, and sometimes larger quibbles - but the progress made over the expansions is great, and by and large everything is really good - as you can tell. My boss reviews (these, anyway) don't have any "bad points" listed, because I really think that all the fights are well done - I do have some quibbles with them, but they're more "things i would do" rather than "things that SHOULD have been done."

Friday, February 13, 2009

Review: Lufia 2: Rise of the Sinistrals

And here's the second part of this series, if a little late.


Lufia 2: Rise of the Sinistrals

Lufia 2 is a really solid SNES RPG. It's a fairly typical sword-and-sorcery RPG set in a pretty typical world. First of all, the targetting system from Lufia was ditched (thankfully), using instead the more typical "target anyone you want with anything" system that most RPG's use. A good choice - like I said earlier, just because something is unique doesn't mean that it's good, or even interesting.

Perhaps the most noticable change between Lufia and Lufia 2 (after the targetting system) is the dungeons. Namely, Lufia 2's dungeons are actually interesting and engaging. They accomplish this by (at least to me, and other people that have played it around me) very well-tuned puzzles. Their solutions aren't usually so obvious as to jump out at you, but also not too hard as to keep you trapped in a dungeon until you look up the solution online. These puzzles are really what makes Lufia 2 a great game - it keeps you thinking, and keeps you interested.

Beyond the well-tuned puzzles to keep dungeons interesting, combat was also made much more interesting with the addition of IP's and capsule monsters. IP's are powers that you can use based on the items you have currently equipped - you use a certain amount of your IP bar (which refills as you get hit) to use an ability that one of your items has - which can range from dealing damage to healing to buffing and pretty much anything else. This makes equipment choice more interesting than in many RPG's, as you have to take into account the item's power rather than just its raw stats. Obviously, however, the main advantage is to give physical characters something to do when they're not just using a basic attack - and it gives casters another option as well.

Capsule monsters, while less important than the IP system, also help to spice up combat, as well as provide you with another thing to do outside of combat. Capsule monsters, in combat, are basically just another party member, with a few restrictions - they can't be directly controlled, and you can't heal them. They are automatically resurrected after battle and healed to full. They provide a source of interesting occurances in battle - you go "yay!" when either the monster wastes a powerful attack hitting the capsule monster, or when the capsule monster does something especially awesome - for example, busting out his most powerful attack and owning an enemy. You collect capsule monsters by finding them throughout the world - in dungeons is a typical place to find them, as a reward for exploring an extra corner of the dungeon. A few are also tucked in different parts of the world that you wouldn't otherwise go to, like an underground cave or a shrine on an obscure island.

Out of combat, capsule monsters are an interesting diversion. You can feed them, and they can evolve to higher forms. You feed them your leftover items. Once they are fed enough, they'll evolve. It seems pretty basic, but it really is an interesting diversion, and something to look forward too when your capsule monster is about to evolve. And seeing their fancy new powers after they've evolved is always fun too.

(This game came out quite a bit pre-pokemon, in case you were wondering and hadn't looked it up.)

Another thing that this game fixed over Lufia 1 is the random battles. No longer are they truly random - you can see (and avoid) the enemy sprites in the dungeon, and actually sneak up on some of them if you're careful. Getting in first on enemies in this game is determined by how your sprites are positioned pre-battle - if you get behind them, you get a free round at the beginning of combat, if they're behind you, they get one. If you are facing their side, then there's something like a 50% chance you'll get in first, and the same thing if they are facing your side. Additionally, you can stun the enemy sprites by shooting them with arrows - a nice feature, and one that can allow you to sneak up on enemies more easily, or simply avoid them if you're not interested. Different enemy types also have different movement patterns in the dungeons - for example, bulls will rush at you, but undead might wander aimlessly. This is yet another thing that really helps bring the dungeons to life in this game.

One interesting thing - while in dungeons you can see the random encounters coming, on the overworld they are truly random. I don't think that the game really suffers for this - the overworld encounters are neither too common nor too hard. The only time that this might be considered annoying is when you're sailing, but even then it's quite reasonable. It's actually kind of nice, if you want to gain a bit of xp or gold that you don't have to track down the enemies, but just wander around on the overworld for a bit.

Also, random encounter difficulty was toned way down, thankfully, as was boss difficulty. One of my few complaints about this game might be that the final bosses are too easy, but all in all, this game's difficulty is far more reasonable and fun than Lufia 1's.

The side quests in Lufia 2 are also much more interesting (and, you know, there) - Lufia 1 had a couple, but generally they just weren't interesting. Lufia 2, however, has a very good casino, collectable dragon eggs, collectable capsule monsters, and the Ancient Cave. I won't get into the details of these, but suffice to say that they're all, especially the Ancient Cave, quite interesting.

Last but certainly not least is the plot. Lufia 2's plot is leaps and bounds above Lufia 1's, and the characters are even better. The plot keeps you engaged, rather than being a snoozefest like Lufia 1's There's not really much more to say about that - it's not exactly the best plot ever, but it does its job just fine, and keeps the players engaged to the end. I will say, however, that the characters are really what keeps you watching - they're just fantastically written, even by today's standards.

That said, Lufia 2 is by no means the perfect game. You still can't see a numerical amount of HP in combat, you just get equal length bars for everyone. The monster translation is still bizzarely terrible compared to the main game's translation - "gorem" instead of "golem" is a common one, and there's many others as well. The battle system, while much more interesting that Lufia 1's, could probably use some work - it's still fairly simplistic, if passable, by today's standards.

Lessons to be learned:

The main thing to learn from Lufia 2 over any other RPG (including Lufia 1) is to learn from the mistakes of the past - see what went wrong with previous games, and correct them. See what previous games did right, and emulate them. Don't just make the same mistakes over and over, and don't abandon what worked in the past.

Capsule monsters are an interesting thing – they are collectible monsters that fight along side you, but they are a relatively minor part of the game. Very few games have monster collection as part of the game and yet minor – I like it. It’s a good way to add pseudo party members with an elemental theme and little to no backstory. Plus, they can serve as good and interesting rewards for particularly challenging puzzles or fights off the beaten path.

An interesting combat system and interesting dungeon design are key. Level designers should be given more credit by players than they are.

A game’s characters and good writing can make up for a relatively formulaic plot and gameplay. City, dungeon, city, dungeon… it’s most of what Lufia is, but it works nonetheless. Indeed, you may fail to even notice it (at least in a bad way) until after you beat the game.



In closing, Lufia 2 is just really a great game that took pretty much everything that was wrong with Lufia 1 and made it awesome, keeping the few good things from Lufia 1. If you can, you should really consider picking this game up. It's a pity that Lufia 3 and 4 aren't more like this game - Lufia 3 borks up the combat system to an extreme degree, and has too many party members. Maybe I'll talk about it sometime, but Lufia 3 seems to have forgotten that just because something is unique doesn't make it good. While its combat system is better than Lufia 1's, it tries to be too interesting and just ends up being less good than the admittedly relatively formulaic Lufia 2's. Additionally, its characters (perhaps because there are so many PC's) just aren't as fun or interesting as Lufia 2's, nor is its plot as good. I've never personally played Lufia 4, but I've heard that it's little more than a mediocre Pokemon clone with a Lufia name and a few characters from Lufia 2.

Next week, I think I'll talk about a couple of genres of games in detail.

Tuesday, February 10, 2009

Review: Lufia and the Fortress of Doom

This week, I'm going to be looking at two games: Lufia and the Fortress of Doom, and its vastly improved sequel, Lufia 2: Rise of the Sinistrals. Lufia 2 is a game that is very near and dear to my heart, and so I thought, why not play the first game in the series? Well, it turns out there are quite a few perfectly valid answers to that question. This is probably going to be an ongoing thing - look at two games that are related, and see just how one of them improves on the other, or doesn't, as the case may be. It's a good way to glean some design knowledge - look at what was dropped from a previous game, and what was added, and think about just why it was done that way.

(For more information about these games, see their wikipedia entry and, perhaps more helpfully, their tvtropes entry.)


Lufia and the Fortress of Doom

An SNES RPG, it embodies everything that has changed about RPG’s since then. First of all, the targeting system in this game was just awful – you could only target groups of enemies, not specific ones, IE if there were three bats and a spider, you could target either the three bats or the spider, and if you targeted the bats and were using a single-target attack, it would hit one of the bats randomly. The only thing I can think that the designers were thinking when they made this was that it would be a unique twist on combat. Well, it was unique, but the lesson to learn here is to actually think whether your “unique twist” is a good/fun idea. This is a lesson many game designers could stand to remember – just because something is unique does not make it fun, or even necessarily interesting.

And it’s not just the dumb targeting system that doesn’t age well about this game. Like so many old RPG’s, it has too many random encounters – and by proxy, it has truly random encounters in general. What I mean by “truly random” is that just walking around triggers them – there’s no way to avoid them, like avoiding their sprite on the dungeon map. Additionally, these random encounters can actually be quite hard – you have to burn a surprisingly high number of spells and items just to make it through a dungeon. And the bosses are harder than that, even – quite a bit of level grinding is required. Fortunately, most modern (but not all – Shin Megami Tensei: Devil Summoner – Raidou Kuzunoha vs. the Soulless Army (what a mouthful) has truly random encounters, and even has them in cities) games have eliminated completely random encounters, and only rarely have ones that are hard enough to be a overbearing tax on your resources.

On a side note, people who remake old games could learn something from new games – there’s a reason very few games have truly random encounters anymore. I’d love to see some older games that, when re-released, didn’t feel the need to keep truly random encounters – Final Fantasies, for example. While I haven’t played the latest release of FF4 for the DS, all the previous remakes of older FF’s I’ve played have kept the truly random encounter system, and it bugs me that they did. Yes, it’s staying true to the original, and yes, it doesn’t require any rebalancing of exp/money gain if you just keep it like it was, but it would improve the game dramatically to fix this.

The translation is actually pretty good, and one of the few saving graces of this game – except for monster names. The team that did the story translation and the team that did the monster translation must have been completely different – the monster names are often completely nonsensical, or simply just strange. For example (while this actually comes from Lufia 2, both games have similar monster naming issues), there is the “Mad Gorem” when the sprite clearly depicts what should be a “Mud Golem.” It’s not that huge of an issue on its own, but it makes you question the quality of the game in general (not that you needed any help doing that for Lufia 1, with its other problems).

The dungeons were also quite boring. There was no spice to the dungeons – you simply walked through all of them until you found the boss, maybe finding some sort of key or other treasure – if you were lucky. There were no puzzles, no random plot events in the middle of dungeons, nothing to really keep you interest. Additionally, their layout was often boring and either too linear or too sprawling – and the aforementioned high frequency and difficulty of random encounters made dungeons in general quite a chore. I had thought this to no longer be the case in any modern RPG, but I recently played Star Ocean: Until the End of Time, and it has a very similar problem. The dungeons in that game are waaaaaaay too big, and frequently have no puzzles or anything to break up their monotony.

It’s not just the targeting system that makes combat in this game annoying. You have “Attack,” “Magic,” “Item,” and “Run” as your only options in battle (and the physical fighters don’t even get Magic). No game has done anything so restrictive in a very long time, and for good reason. You simply have far too few options in combat in this game.

The plot also deserves mentioning. It’s incredibly one-dimensional. I mentioned this in my pacing article, but the meta-plot of this game is always the same. You’re always trying to stop the Sinistrals. Occasionally you vary in exactly how you’re trying to stop them – finding someone who knows about them, finding a powerful weapon to fight them, actually confronting them – but it’s always the same overall goal. There’s also a few subplots, but they’re always very clearly subplots, and frankly, none of them are that interesting.

Lastly, there are a few smaller issues worth mentioning – first of all, you can’t see your numerical max hp/mp in combat, only a bar that was a representation of the percent your characters were at. While that usually sufficed, the difference between the HP of your casters and melee characters was large enough make this annoying. You also couldn’t see what items out of combat (and I forget if you even could in combat) – or maybe it was the other way around. Maybe it was that you only couldn’t see them when you were about to buy them. Regardless, you should always be able to see what the items you have can do. This goes for spells too, as I mentioned in my earlier post, “Things Games Should Never/Always Have.” Again, I thought that this was a thing that only occurred in old games, but Persona 3 had this problem for spells, and it was quite annoying – fortunately, Persona 4 fixed that problem.

So, you might ask me (and justifiably so), did this game do anything right? First of all, there’s something to be said for judging something outside its time. When this game was released, the RPG genre wasn’t was it is today – standards were different. (Excessive) Truly random encounters were the norm, and “Fight/Magic/Item/Run” was pretty typical as well. So in its day, it was probably a passable, but unexceptional, RPG. However, one thing that this game does do right is its characters. They are fairly compelling and deep, especially for their day. Even if the plot itself was fairly uninteresting, the characters still managed to bring it to life. Indeed, the indeed characters are probably the only reason that this game got a sequel. Not that I’m sad that it did – Lufia 2, as I mentioned earlier, is a fantastic SNES-era RPG not to be missed, even now, but after having played this game, it does make me wonder slightly just how it did manage to get a sequel.


Lessons to be learned:

Truly random encounters should be history. Encounters should be avoidable. More generally, make recurring potentially annoying things in games avoidable.

Make sure your gimmick actually works and is fun. (Combat targeting, in this case.)

Max HP – let me see it at all times. In number form, or in bars that are of different sizes. Basically, don't make the player work to see how much HP his party has left, and more generally, don't make the player work for information that he should have. Of course, this brings up a whole different issue of "just how much information should I give the player," but that's an article for a different day - for now, let's just go with: max and current HP values, what different stats do (generally), and what your different items and spells do.

Make your dungeons(and more generally, levels) interesting! Good backdrops, puzzles (mostly this), and some character interaction can go a long way. Something to break the standard pattern.

Let me see descriptions of anything at any time. (Items, Magic, in this case.)

Don’t make random encounters (and more generally, your repetative things that happen in non-boss encounters) too hard! Or if you do, autoheal to full after every fight. See: Baten Kaitos Origins.

Don’t make the meta-plot stale, or if you must, make the subplots interesting.

Tuesday, February 3, 2009

Review: Psychonauts

Psychonauts

Psychonauts is a entertaining platformer/action game, along the lines of Banjo-Kazooie. It generally has a rather silly atmosphere – people’s brains get popped out by sneezing powder, the script is generally hilarious, and the worlds themselves are often whimsical. However, the game also has darker moments – people’s brains are getting stolen by the evil drill sergeant, and the final level – the “meat circus” – is very nightmarish.

The gameplay itself is quite good. You have all the basic abilities of most BK-ish games – jump, double-jump, and punch to start with, and over time, you gain new psychic abilities – levitation (which is really just super-jumping combined with gliding), pyrokinesis (nifty, but dangerous – you can set yourself on fire of you hit someone that’s too close), telekinesis (not handled as cool as in Psi-Ops or Destroy All Humans – here, you have to stand still to use telekinesis, and you can only move other objects by tossing them, not walking around with them), Invisibility (quite nifty, even if it isn’t greater invisibility), Clairvoyance (not particularly useful – lets you see through the eyes of others), Blast (basic mind laser), Shield (reflects projectiles, blocks attacks, makes you stand still – handy, but something of a game breaker if used correctly, especially against the final boss – but not too bad of one), and Stun Grenades (pretty handy, I assume – I didn’t use them much). All in all, a pretty decent arsenal for such a game, even if some of the powers are of questionable usability.

The worlds themselves are rather zany – the idea is, you go inside people’s minds and solve their mental problems or pass some sort of test. The worlds, thus, tend to be somewhat kooky – a spy who thinks she should be a TV star has a very bright, colorful party brain, a man with multiple personalities (one of them being Napoleon) is playing a board game in his mind with Napoleon, which you go into and win, and an insane mailman has a conspiracy-filled neighborhood in which you look for “the milkman.” The level design is usually quite good – the platforming is never too easy or too hard, and the bosses are a bit on the easy side, but not too bad – that’s really to be expected, given the genre.

Really, I don't see how this game got a reputation as being wildly original. I suppose its story premise is pretty unique - psychic camp, go inside people's minds as levels, but the gameplay is very little that Banjo-Kazooie didn't already cover. Don't get me wrong, I really liked Psychonauts, but the reputation it's gotten strikes me as odd.

Lessons to be learned:

Zany worlds are fun, if you can do it right. Never knowing exactly what’s going to happen in the next world is quite cool. Of course, the player should never worry about what’s coming next – the levels need to be good in zany ways, not lame in zany ways.

A good array of powers is key. Make people look forward to getting the next power.

Upgrading existing powers in fun ways is also quite nice, and is a good thing for collectibles to grant.

Tuesday, January 27, 2009

Review: Turtles in Time

Turtles IV: Turtles in Time

One of my all-time favorite co-op games, Turtles in Time is an arcade-port co-op sidescrolling beat-em-up game. You play as one of the four Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles, each of whom has slightly different stats – speed, power, range, hp. You are assaulted by enemies of various types – color-coded for your convenience, naturally, followed by a boss at the end of each level. There's a token plot about Shredder stealing the Statue of Liberty, and the later sending you in to a time warp (which he just happened to have lying around?), but the plot is mostly in the background for the course of the game. Of course, these things could describe virtually any co-op beat-em-up. What is important is what sets Turtles in Time apart.

1) Fast pace. This is the number one thing any beat-em-up game needs. Not just hurling enemy after enemy at you (though that’s a start), but making them have different abilities so that you have to think on your feet, and still making it feel like you progress through the level at a speedy pace. This is what a good beat-em-up game needs – diversity among enemies, and a fast pace. Additionally, the characters themselves move quite quickly, which adds to the definite feeling of fast-paced-ness. Slow characters are the devil.

1a) Good pacing, time-wise. Levels do not drag on – they each last a fair amount of time, but you don’t feel cheated, nor do you ever say “ugh will this level just END.” The game itself, as well, is a quick beat - ~45 minutes from start to finish, but it doesn’t feel rushed. It leaves you wanting more, sure, but only in the way that everything good does.

2) Differentiated characters. Of course, most games these days have this in spades, and I have to admit it’s not a huge factor in this game. But it’s there, and that’s important. The four turtles are not carbon copies of each other – each plays slightly differently. Like I say, it’s the little things.

3) Adjustable difficulty. Every game should have this, or virtually every game, anyway. Turtles in Time does it well – there are noticeable differences between difficulties, in bosses and mooks, and not just “damage x2.”

4) Good, customizable controls. You’d think this would be a gimme, but even these days, this sort of thing can be screwed up.

5) Lots of different moves. There were the grabs (2 kinds), normal combos, super attacks, power-ups, aerial attacks, and two kinds of running attacks. And yet, you can pretty much always do the attack that you want at any given time, and the attacks are all useful. Much, much better than punch (into a combo) and jump that some other games have.

6) Sound. From the “Oh, shell-shocked” and “Cowabunga” to the background music, it all fits the atmosphere brilliantly, and keeps the spirit of the cartoon.

7) Good level design. The obstacles all fit the themes of the various levels, and none come off as really annoying. None are too hard to dodge, but they definitely have to be kept in mind while you fight. Plus, the backgrounds are well done, and you get the feeling that you’re moving through an area and making progress.

Lessons to be learned from Turtles in Time:

With arcade-style beat-em-ups, and arcade-style games in general, (and all games!) it’s all about the pacing. Additionally, differentiation among enemy types helps greatly to keep the game going, where other similar games might fail – especially if none of the enemies are super-annoying.

Sunday, January 25, 2009

Review: Psi-Ops

A review I did of a game some time ago. It's set from my standard perspective of analyzing a game for what makes it fun, and what doesn't. I don't talk about it in the review, but the pacing in this game is quite good. Pacing is a very, very powerful idea, and one that I'll expound more on this Tuesday.

Psi-Ops: The Mindgate Conspiracy

Psi-Ops is a fairly decent Sci-Fi FPS. It’s plot is okay – nothing spectacular, but certainly passable. You infiltrate the bad guy’s base, using your guns and your psi powers to kill bunches of people, recover special moon rocks, and save the world from the evil general. Evil twins and psychically-themed villains abound.

The psi powers, to me, are the highlight of this game. You have telekinesis, remote viewing (AKA astral projection), Mind Control, pyrokinesis, and “sense aura” (a cheesy, puzzle-only power). Pyrokinesis, sadly, is just another gun, effectively, and sense aura could’ve been a handy-dandy infrared-vision, but no, just a lame puzzle-solving power.

The FPS combat is nothing exemplary – it’s a lot like many others, with a minor difference in the auto-aiming dot that aims for a body part and shows you which. Don’t do this. Auto-aiming, if it has to exist, should be largely behind the scenes – plus, this wasn’t done that well – it made it harder at times to aim at heads. Also! Hit detection = terrible. Sniping someone’s head was nigh-impossible. For goodness sake, test your hit detection, people.

I do, however, commend this game for having co-op, difficulty levels, and creative uses of telekinesis (hold them with one hand, shoot with the other; rolly balls of doom) and mind-control (Finally, a “kill yourself” option!). That said, Pyrokinesis should have just lit the target on fire, or pierced/worked around terrain to make it more than just a gun that ran on psi. Aura View should also have been infrared vision, more distinctly than it already was.

Also, rolling balls of telekinetic doom = awesome.

Lessons to be learned:

Don’t give me powers just to make fricking everyone immune to them at the end. Balance your game without resorting to such cheap tricks.

Don’t ever, ever give me a move or item that is only useful when you say it is. Ever! Zelda games could learn from this, as well. I’m looking at you, statue-controlly rod from Twilight Princess. (If you absolutely, positively have to do this, scatter things that I can use it on throughout the game, not just at puzzle-solving points.)
-Actually, the real problem is when one out of a set of useful things is only useful when you say it is. For example, when I go through a Zelda dungeon, I will get a nifty new item. In addition to this item being necessary for me to complete the dungeon, I expect it to be just generally useful. When it isn’t, I am disappointed. However, I’m perfectly willing to accept songs (a la Ocarina of Time or Wind Waker) that are only useful when you say they are, because all songs are like that. It’s only when you break the “useful” mold and give me something that isn’t that I get annoyed.

Auto-aiming needs to be less annoying and blatant.

Dear god, test your hit-detection. Sniping should WORK.

Guns and powers should be separate. Powers should not just be guns that run on Psi.

Creative uses of telekinesis = win.

Tuesday, January 20, 2009

Review: Zombies Ate My Neighbors

Originally Posted December 18, 2008 at adamgameapprentice.blogspot.com:

I'd like to start doing two posts a week, roughly - one will contain something that I've already written, and one will be original for that week. My "Original" post for today will be a review of an older game that you may or may not have heard of called "Zombies Ate My Neighbors."

Obviously, with a title like that, it isn't a game that takes itself very seriously. The game an SNES and Genesis arcade-style top-down action game in which you play as one of two functionally-identical kids, a boy or a girl. Armed with a water gun, popsicles, soda cans, crosses, Martian Bubble Guns, and the like, you fight off hordes of undead and other monsters in an attempt to defeat the poorly-developed Dr. Tongue.

Honestly, this game is almost exactly what it tries to be - an enjoyable arcade-style action game that you can pick up, play for a while and have some fun, then come back to it later, or that you can play for a long time and attempt to beat. However, because this game isn't in an arcade, it has several flaws. One thing: It's too hard. The game starts fairly easy, and has health packs that you can pick up and use later, but the difficulty in later levels is over-the-top. The evil dolls, chainsaw murderers, and (oh god) sand worms are especially vicious, not to mention hard-to-avoid. Not only that, but if you continue from a password, you lose all your special items and weapons. Simply put, this game needs a couple of things to make it work - the option of lower difficulty, and save files. Don't get me wrong, I love a good challenging game, but without the option to save effectively, and without the possibility of a lower difficulty, it just isn't fun.

The plot in this game is almost entirely explained in the instruction manual. One change that could be made there would be to have the standard "intro plot" of most arcade games, where if you just leave the controller lying there the plot rolls before you start the game. That would be nice. Additionally, some sort of after-level plot (complete with cheesy narrating?) would be nice, if not after every level, then after every five or so. This game was practically tailor-made for the cheesy plot of a B-movie - the level names and general tone of the game are basically a playable B-movie, after all - so it's a pity that one wasn't included.
Another thing about this game is the length. Again, don't get me wrong, I love a good long game, but the challenge and annoyance of passwords makes this game feel like it drags on. I think that this problem would be mostly fixed by adding in very brief bits of cheesy plot, lower difficulty, and a better save option.

There are several things that this game does do right. The biggest thing that this game gets right that kills many action games is variety. Variety of enemies, variety of weapons, variety of power-ups, variety of level design - this game gets it right. The enemies are many and varied, the power-ups (like the inflatable clown decoys! Brilliant! If annoying-sounding) are fantastic, and the weapons are inspired. The level design is also very well-done (if challenging) - big thumbs-up to whoever did the level design for this game. The neighborhood, warehouse, shopping mall, hedge maze, and all the other levels all feel different and great. The pacing, similarly, is well done, largely because of the variety of things - though interjecting bits of plot between levels would add to it.

One other thing to complain about is having to wander around to find the last hostage. The radar is nice, but the levels are annoyingly large at times, and it's often very difficult to get to the hostages before the undead do. It's hard to find a solution here - making it less linear would be one way to do it, but I love the large stages. One solution might be to let you leave a level after you rescue, say half or three-quarters of the hostages - you can progress without having to scour the level for the path to get to the last hostage, but you lose some points that you would have gotten. Or at least giving you an item that lets you do this - maybe once every couple of levels you get another "get out of this level free" item? I think making the levels at least a bit more linear would help, or have the radar be more helpful (when there's tons of obstacles in my way, knowing which general direction to go isn't a great help).

There's not much to say about the graphics - they are pretty good for the SNES/Genesis, and fit the atmosphere.
The sound is also quite good - though there are effects that are annoying, and BGM's that really get on my nerves. That said, everything fits the tone of the game, so that's something. Slightly less annoying music and sound effects would be great, or at least the ability to change their relative volume.

Basically, this game needs a bit polish for it to shine, but it is already quite a good game, considering when it was made. An update would include difficulty levels, save files, some sort of option to get out of a level without wandering around it, slightly more linear levels - or at least some better way to tell where to go, slightly different sound, and bits of plot here and there. Then it would be the game that it tried to be, pretty much perfectly, at least to me - a quirky, retro-feeling fun little action game with an undead theme. It still wouldn't make anyone's "best games of all time" list, probably, but it would be fun for those who like the genre, and a solid little game - maybe an 8. Not especially outstanding, but certainly worth playing, and worth beating if you get some solid enjoyment out of it.

Review: Geist

Originally posted December 1st, 2008:

Let's go ahead and start this with a bang. This is, admittedly, old stuff - I wrote this a bit ago, but I feel just as passionate about it now as I did then. It's about a Gamecube game that most of you probably haven't heard of, much less actually played, called Geist.
Geist is a pseudo-FPS made by Nintendo, of all people, on the Gamecube. Its main feature that I want to talk about and remember in this is, well, its main feature.

In Geist, you are a ghost who can possess people and objects name John Raimi (silent protaganist), with the ultimate goals of stopping the BBEG and reclaiming your body, which you were separated from at the beginning of the game. During the game, you learn more about the BBEG by exploring his base and interacting with his ghostly sister, Gigi, who is an appropriately creepy (and quite helpful) little ghost girl. But the possession aspect is what makes this game so great. I want to talk about it on two levels – on the level of it, specifically, and on what I can learn from it in regards to the genre shuffle style.

The possession mechanic, first and foremost, is brilliant. You can possess various people, and thus gain various abilities that allow you to move on in the game, or combat foes in new and special ways. It also allows an element of stealth – after all, it’s not always easy to tell when someone is being possessed.

However, the idea is not taken as far as it could be. Only certain people can be possessed – usually, those who are next to objects that you can possess in order to frighten them. It feels like a “necessary” cop-out – the game designers liked the premise, but couldn’t figure out a way to make it work logically without being overpowered. Frankly, this is really annoying – if possession of others is my superpower, then I should be able to use it, gosh darn it. This is somewhat subverted, however, in that you can detonate explosives to kill enemy soldiers, or control gun turrets to shoot enemies. However, by the same token, shouldn’t you have been able to possess guns to make them fire, or doors to make them open?

One particularly brilliant segment is defending your black friend from many soldiers by possessing various objects and using them to defeat the soldiers attacking him. You control gun turrets, detonate explosives, and even manually roll grenades to their feet, detonating them.

Unfortunately, the next segment is somewhat more limited – though awesome in concept, its execution is lacking. Your aforementioned black friend is on a motorcycle, attempting to escape the complex that is the setting for much of the game. You can possess his motorcycle, moving him, you can possess explosives, detonating them in an attempt to halt pursuit – or you can mostly just possess the gun on the back of the truck in front of him, using it to gun down all other problems. Blah – while an interesting use of the possession mechanic, the possession mechanic itself felt paradoxically underused in the scene. Perhaps a more appropriate setting for such an event would be on a helicopter turret, or some such.

The rat segment is again a bit of brilliance – you possess a rat and attempt to return it to its owner, and in order to do so, you must avoid a series of mousetraps. However, your possessed host, the rat, is drawn to the cheese on the traps in an almost magnetic fashion. So in order to escape, you must avoid the traps and make your way safely back to the rat’s owner. It’s a brilliant use of the possession mechanic (even if why you can’t possess the mousetraps and set them off beforehand isn’t adequately explained).

The rat example brings me to my next point – the use of repeated genre swapping in this game. The thing is, though, it doesn’t feel like it is. Each use of the possession mechanic in a new way feels natural – the rat, the various people, missile turrets. To further this idea, your hosts are given different weapons – some hosts have shotguns, some (one, disappointingly) have a sniper rifle with a heat-vision component, some (one, again) have rocket launchers. The overall effect is that each host, animal, human, or usable object, feels like a new experience – and it’s pulled off brilliantly. This is emphasized by the fact that animals see limited to no colors, and your ghostform has its own blued-out vision as well – human hosts and mechanical objects see normally, though the perspective of inanimate objects is often entertaining. (Of course, your own body is the best form for combat – a very nice automatic weapon and anti-ghost grenades, along with the ability to go bullet-time – quite awesome, though a bit of explanation as to how that last part worked would have been nice.) As an added bonus, despite the fact that the final boss is fought in a moderately different way than anything before him, it doesn’t feel forced – in other words, it manages to (to some degree) avoid the annoyance of Star Fox Adventures, Mystical Ninja Starring Goemon, and Banjo-Tooie with the “random genre swap” final boss, by setting up a reasonable premise and keeping the shift moderate.

Lessons to be learned:

Possession is an excellent, underused mechanic with a lot of room for unique growth in future games. Taking control of your enemies = awesome!

Rapid genre swaps can work (in a non-party game setting) if you set up a logical premise for them, and don’t make the shift too dramatic.

If I were to remake the game:

Make pretty much everyone and everything possessable. While the “scaring” mechanic is a good start for limiting possession, it’s too limiting – set up circumstances that can be used to scare any given NPC (save bosses, of course, unless that’s the trick). Possessing a soldier’s gun, for example – or simply the light fixtures or PA – would be a viable way to make this work. This would also mean that, in the example of protecting the black friend, for example, that while possessing the actual people doing the shooting would be possible, it would be much more practical to do it the way that was intended. It would also give the game a much-needed sense of “more than one way to do things.”

Alternately, be able to possess anyone, but if they are not scared first, then you have only limited control over them, as well as only temporary control, similar to when ghosts possess you towards the end of the game.

Make more objects possessable, preferably everything. I’m on the fence as to whether simply not allowing doors to be opened in ghostform with no explanation is worse than trying to provide an explanation for it. If most everything is possessable, give a way to turn on/off seeing the auras around what’s possessable, in degrees – objects, people.

Spend more time in the simulator at the beginning, and when we go back, let it complete and only maintain your individuality by Gigi sneaking into the sim and helping you fight the brainwashing, or your memories of her/your family/whatever.

Things used to scare people would be possessable in any order. (Ladder, extinguisher, and pipes in any order, not just that order.)

Dear God! Higher difficulty levels! I mean, really!

Co…op? Somehow? Maybe? *shrug*

Grenades! Throw->Possess->Roll->Explode.

Flying hosts – invertable

Possessions should be quicker to initiate. I loved simply being able to slip out of a body – slipping back into one should’ve been just as natural.

The story would be deeper, and Raimi wouldn’t have been silent.

The game would have been 2-3x as long.


Multiplayer Changes:

Online, online, online. Bigger maps – this game could be the next Halo if done right.

Better ammo/gun system. Direct Halo rip?

Capture the flag.

Ghost Barriers!

Vehicles! Possessable, of course.

New Toggles:
Ghosts – invisible to non-ghosts
Ghosts – invisible on radar
Ghosts – damageable
Ghosts – pop out of hosts when the host dies, or respawn back at their base
Hosts – damage transfer between them
Hosts/Vehicles – possessable only by certain teams
Ghosts – limited possession of already possessed hosts
Objects – indicator of whether or not the object is being possessed